Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[psyah]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@Mr.Popat

I want to know if what i explained in post 137 has anything wrong in it
Heres the link to that post again.
http://www.paklinks.com/gs/religion-and-scripture/562810-details-of-interpreting-verses-from-the-quran-and-obvious-blunders-7.html#post8980988

5:75 : The Messiah, son of Mary, was not but a messenger; [other] messengers have passed on before him. And his mother was a supporter of truth. They both used to eat food. Look how We make clear to them the signs; then look how they are deluded.

In addition to my response to this verse in my post 137 (link given).. I would also like to add some more.

psyah has said that this verse was in response that jesus cannot be god since he ate and God does not eat. Ok thats fair enough.

God does not eat.. Jesus ‘used’ to eat. He does not eat anymore.

Messengers before him have died..so did He. But God does not die.

Why do you emphasis on one point and totally ignore the other point being made in the verse ?

It should be understood like this :

Since God does NOT eat and NEVER dies.. Jesus A.S ‘used to eat’ AND he died like other messengers. Therefore, he CANNOT be God.

You are giving christians a possibility to still say that He “CAN” be God by him still being alive. God refused even this little confusion by saying that He was just a messenger. messengers like him have passed away, and he used to eat. God neither eats, nor dies. Messengers die and they also eat.

This is the way of Allah. He explains his verses in a very clear way. Beautiful is His ways of conveying message.

Are you saying that only one condition of ‘eating’ applies to God and not of death ?

Peace Bigboi

If someone ate food and never died can he claim to be God? What does it say in your aqeedah? For us eating food is a sign of being mortal … not being self-subsistent … eating food means one takes nourishment from something else other than what is within it … Even if that entity did not die … the true Muslims will never claim it to be God … because they know that God does not eat … so understand! You have no argument here … If Allah (SWT) so Wills He can keep Isa (AS) alive forever just like He promises to keep the jannatis alive forever …

You are fixated over one semi-aspect of Divine attribute … Allah (SWT) has no beginning, no mother, no end, does not eat … Muslims believe that Isa (AS) will eventually die, hada mother and ate food … even if we don’t believe him to die at all it takes nothing away from Allah (SWT) because the everlasting life of Allah (SWT) is within the Being of Allah … but if anything lives forever that is not Allah (SWT) it can only do so by Allah (SWT) providing that sustaining power.

You need to understand tawheed properly … and I recommend your leaders who bring this stale argument to do the same …