Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[Mr.Popat]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@Ibn_Sadique

Popat Yes I did manage to write a lot (in fact quite a lot) – I did point out on the onset that:

Alhamdulillah, I think I managed to refute all that you and others (like you)had to say. Time is limited so, I don’t promise that I’ll be able to respond to your post. Of course you can say what you want but this is going to be very repetitive.

So, probably I’ll let you have the last say unless of course you state something very extraordinaire. (My fear is that you will do so )

But by saying the following you have inadvertently hit the crux the problem.

I have no intention of repeating same thing over and over. My request is pretty straight forward. I ask your interpretation on 3 verses in which im debating on. Dont beat bushes here and there. Explain it to me if theres such an incident where someone had lived outside of Earth without proper measure and still remained alive. 2) explain me the verse in which it says that Messengers before Muhammad have passed away.. 3) explain me in clear manner what the verse meant where it says that Messiah was just a messenger..messengers like him have passed away before him. I need answer to these questions before anything else.

You, I mean Ahmadis claim to believe Prophet Muhammad (saw) to be superior to Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, that’s just a claim, reality is different – there are enough statements from MGA that he is in reality the Second Advent of Prophet Muhammad (saw) and if I remember correctly the second advent is more enhanced!

As you state in the above quotation that you “believe in Him as prophet, what He said is a hujjat on us. We do not question what He (as) say” and you stated the following too, “we are not to question prophets”.

Without a doubt, and it is obvious to the viewers here that you are ‘slavishly loyal’ to the utterances of MGA BUT are questioning and rejecting the sayings of Prophet Muhammad (saw)!!!

Whereas I (and those like me) are ‘slavishly loyal’ to the sayings of Prophet Muhammad (saw)and rejecting everything MGA states.

You (Ahmadis) interpret Quran, ahadith and Sunnah in the light of “WAHI” received by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad; therein in lies the problem between us.

You are purposely spreading false information. Have fear of Allah.

If a christian was to say the same to you that you are ‘slavishly loyal’ to the sayings of Muhammad PBUH and not think ..im not sure how your reaction to that would be like..

But yeah, we need to first understand if Hazrat Ahmad (as) was saying all this “AS” a prophet or not. If AS a prophet, then prophets are not to be questioned. Just like Muhammad PBUH is not to be questioned for whatever he said. Muhammad PBUH said that there is not a single group of people on Earth who were not warned of Dajjal by their respective messengers. Have you ever asked your scholars and questioned Muhammad pbuh’s prophethood by asking him to show you just 2 evidences from any of their books mentioning dajjal ? you dont ask right? why not ? Because he is hujjat to you as a prophet. Will you question Jesus (as)? Just curious

That is why… before raising any point, think once if you are not letting go islam from your hands.