Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

Answer to this is in post 157.
You see, this belief or assumption that Adam a.s lived in heaven ..so can Jesus a.s got vanished too :slight_smile:
I was merely saying and debating from your view point…i was also right to say that the verse ‘therein shall you live’ was said after Adam came to Earth.

But thats another story. All souls are said to be created..and humans to be born. If in the tafseer it had said that Adam a.s did indeed live in the heaven in which people go after their death, yeah then you can use that against me.. but frankly.. now, you need to tackle this belief first whether the heaven was on Earth or was Allah talking about the heaven which is the ultimate place? Like I said, thats another topic..and i did not want to get into this. My point was very straight forward and easy to understand… ‘therein shall you live’ was said after adam was sent to Earth.

lol !
When you do not have answer to questions.. this is how you end it?

I’m waiting for your response about the verse of Muhammad PBUH’s death and Messiah a.s death and prophets before them dying. Why you take them irrelevant is beyond my understanding.