Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders
You said it is relating to 4 individuals but fail to show me a single instance in which human being had lived outside of the Earth, ofcourse without any proper measures. It is naive to think that Adam and 3 other individual (according to you) were the only ones told to live on Earth. Rest of them are free to be living anywhere else.. this was not proved by you. Humans do tend to live ON Earth.. anywhere outside, they DIE!.. why should I not use that verse to mean every humanbeing then ? It is easy to say that the verse contains exceptions.. i asked you to make exceptions in the verse and tell me what you can come up with. Yet you did not take this question seriously either. Just saying it has exception is not good enough :). None of the verse you provided which disproves my understanding of the verse.
Wrong. People cannot live in heaven. You telling me that if Adam lived, so can anyone else is false idea to begin with. You need to first see if the verse if only limited to 4 individual or for everyone. If it is for 4 only, then we should be able to live outside the Earth. The verse was said after Adam came to Earth. So, no, doesnt make sense.
O deeaaaaarr !!!
Now you are going to tell me heaven is a physical place. I dont want to talk about that. No matter whatever shape it is in, it is outside the Earth, we cannot get there alive. We can experience heaven or hell in this very life..but that will occur while us being on earth, heaven and hell which are the ultimate abode will be only after death.
If you see the event of miraj, muhammad pbuh saw jesus a.s and yahya a.s in 2nd heaven. One alive, while another dead. Can you explain this ?
Keep in mind that dead do not accompany alive. (I can explain this statement in brief too, but I hope you’re smart enough to know what I mean).
I still say humans can ONLY live on Earth. Allah said so. You are changing the meaning of verses according to your beliefs rather than changing your beliefs according to Quranic verses. Trust me you are! May Allah soften your heart and enable you to see whole Quran and not just one verse and then make a belief and then no matter what is given to you, you will keep creating exceptions in it. May He forgives what you do. ameen.
No hard feelings. Forgive me if i had said any harsh words against you. I never meant to offend you in anyway. Respects for what you do in love of Islam and to keep your beliefs intact no matter what… but in the end, its the Quran’s word that will prevail and is prevailing alhamdulillah.