Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders
Mr.Popat … :nono:
Here are you claims in this small section of your response … You throw your balls of falsehood hoping that I’ll miss one …
A) You say I can’t get rid of the fact that Allah says Earth is the abode for living and dead …
Actually you have a bad memory … I did show you that this verse was relating to 4 individuals who would live and die on this Earth … I showed you that this verse has exception in it. And lastly I have never attempted to disprove the truth of this verse, but to show you that it is not an absolute verse meant for absolutely every situation … I did this by qualifying it against other verses and with the Arabic language.
B) You ask me what verse I came up with … I directly answered your idea (not from the Quran but from your mind) that this Earth is ONLY place where humans can live … I showed you that is a false notion … People can, will and do live in heaven … And they can and will live in Jahannum.
C) There is not a single verse that we have talked about so far that mandates death before we get to see heaven or Auzdubillah hell … We are talking about norms … But then you are trying to limit the ways of Allah to norms … That He will not make miracles … Not even for prophets.
D) You said that I can’t disprove 7:25 … Astaghfirullah … Does it look like that I am trying to disprove the Holy Book? I’m merely showing up your flimsy understanding … And your ever erroneous statements …just go back and read your statements … It was you who said that “humans can ONLY live on Earth” what a foolish statement to make and then say that I am trying to disprove the verse …
The thing I am doing is showing up the problems in our understanding and how to satisfy the basic tenets … You end up bending or even breaking many others.