Defence Day of Pakistan - 6th September 1965

[Anwer_Pasha]

Re: Defence Day of Pakistan - 6th September 1965

@Dronacharya

^
Pasha Saheb,
There is no difference between the “dirty” deeds of India and Pakisan. Pakistan also invaded Balochistan after its independence, and denied Independence option to Pashtuns. Each Dominion tried to get control of as much territory as possible. The concern for natives was superficial. The main struggle was for the control of resources on their respective territories.
In Kashmir,the Raja was already weak, and his regime collapsing. Sh. Abdullah was immensely popular. Revolution had already broken.I am sure J&K would soon have gained independence. However, this was not in Pakistan’s interest because of the stormy relationship between Quaid and Sheikh. Thus, the invasion by *kabaili lashkars *was launched from Pakistan, which incidentally also gave India the pretext that she needed to intervene. The rest, as they say, is history.
India is not disliked for playing dirty, she is disliked for outmaneuvering Pakistan every time in playing dirty.

This is not true . Pajistan didn’t invade Baluchistan . They joined Pakistan themselves . Pashtones opted Pakistan through a referendum
Invade through Qabaili lashkar was a foolishness , They should have to leave it in local fighters who were doing it better .

[Dronacharya]

Re: Defence Day of Pakistan - 6th September 1965

@Anwer_Pasha

This is not true . Pajistan didn’t invade Baluchistan . They joined Pakistan themselves . Pashtones opted Pakistan through a referendum .

Circumstances surrounding Kalat’s accession to Pakistan are even more murkier as compared to that of Kashmir to India. Similarly, Pakhtunkhwa’s referendum was boycotted by the province’s most popular political party and their tallest leader because of exclusion of “Independence” option. Still Pakistan only won it by a slight majority of 50.1%. Did it make the exercise legal ? Sure. But was it moral or ethical ? Decide for yourself.

Like I said before, Is hamam mein dono nange hain, no point in arguing who is carrying more dirt !

Now I am out of this thread, before I get banned

[Anwer_Pasha]

Re: Defence Day of Pakistan - 6th September 1965

There is always troubles in matters like this . Khan of Qalat was double minded but he decided just himself without any military threat . I don’t want to quote here the reason because that is immaterial . Our history is clean but later our army men started mistakes .

[mo293]

Re: Defence Day of Pakistan - 6th September 1965

@Dronacharya

Can you point me to the mysterious books in which these mythologies are written. Not a newspaper article or anecdotal reports but real history books, that are taught in India. Here you can access some of these books:
National Council Of Educational Research And Training :: Home

I think both of you are confused. You are mistaking war-time propaganda with actual history. When a war is being fought, all kinds of fantastic claims might be made for increasing morale of the populace.This is called war-time propaganda. But, after the dust settles down, scholars sit down to do an objective assessment of mistakes and achievements of the war. This is called history. In some countries, both might be synonymous, but not in India.

You are absolutely right every body is a liar and Neville Maxvell is the biggest liar - And look at the reviews of the book below…Even bigger lies. Neville is a scum.. LMAO…

India's China War: MAXWELL, Neville.: 9780394470511: Amazon.com: Books

Rest easy - We only believe and read Indian shistory its the absolute truth nothing but the truth.

[Ali_Syed]

Re: Defence Day of Pakistan - 6th September 1965

@Dronacharya

Circumstances surrounding Kalat’s accession to Pakistan are even more murkier as compared to that of Kashmir to India. Similarly, Pakhtunkhwa’s referendum was boycotted by the province’s most popular political party and their tallest leader because of exclusion of “Independence” option. Still Pakistan only won it by a slight majority of 50.1%. Did it make the exercise legal ? Sure. But was it moral or ethical ? Decide for yourself.

Like I said before, Is hamam mein dono nange hain, no point in arguing who is carrying more dirt !

Now I am out of this thread, before I get banned

When the referendum in NWFP was held the country was run by the Brits (therefore they decided the bits and pieces of the referendum), Congress was ruling the province, the khudai khidmatgars boycotted the elections as there was no option for independence. The result of the elections was in favour of Pakistan. If the Khudai khidmatgars were so popular why havent they been able to muster popular support in elections in the province, as far as I know ANP (previously NAP) is currently ruling the province for the first time since independence. As far as Balochistan is concerned, the whole province except Kalat state joined Pakistan. Some people raise doubts about the circumstances in which Kalat acceded to Pakistan.

[farisriaz]

Re: Defence Day of Pakistan - 6th September 1965

You can also read Defence Day Pakistan 6 September 1965 History in Urdu