[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by PyariCgudia: *
For example, you can judge this picture against American movies, or Indian movies. Or you can judge them against other Pakistani movies. What is more fair to the industry?
[/QUOTE]
Or you can judge this movie (whatever it is) by the choices afforded to the viewer. Those who have a choice will compare it to the best Hollywood, Europe or Asia has to offer and give it failing grade just by choosing not to watch it. Someone else who either doesn't have this option or will want to watch anything "Made in Pakistan", may consider it to be a very good shot.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by PyariCgudia: *
Pak film industry has gotten into this really big accident, and a patient in critical condition isn't cured immediately. There is therapy involved. And that takes a lot of time. It takes a long time to build something, but its a matter of minutes to break what you've built.
[/QUOTE]
Actually I don't think Pak film industry got into a big accident or they broke up something in a matter of minutes. Bad movies come out from all places, including Hollywood. That doesn't bog down a whole industry. The Pakistani film industry, in my view, committed themselves to a long process of slow-poison. From the hey days of 60's and 70's when they had talented directors, writers, musicians and actors, they went into the 80's and 90's where the art took a back seat to make money. I can write on and on about what I believe ails our film industry, and maybe I will sometime, but one thing is sure. It was very deliberate, very knowing, and an extended process. The cure is equally elaborate, and means a complete overhaul of the whole system.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by PyariCgudia: *
1. something different. Main problem the industry is facing: lack of experimentation. No one wants to go past the maula jutt style movies.
[/QUOTE]
I would hope that Maula Jatt time passed a long time ago, and if alive, is probably only in a limited number of punjabi movies. Urdu movies and a lot of Punjabi movies moved on to newer things years ago.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by PyariCgudia: *
2. style - maybe what they're wearing is not something we would wear, but this is an art - the whole point is that you get to see characters in get-ups that accent the emotions. Dress style is important, and at least here, they've gone past the lachas and dhotis.
[/QUOTE]
errr..... I wouldn't put down lachas and dhotis if the character demands it and if the movie is about something related to the whole thing (a village setting, maybe). Like it or not, a lot of people in Pakistan do wear dhotis and lachas and whatnot. What they hardly ever wear is mini-skirts or knee-length skirts. And this is my biggest gripe. I fear our film industry goes to an extra few miles to imitate H/Bollywood and gets detached from the message they are trying to convince. If the character is a foreigner who'd wear a western dress as part of the role, thats proly fine, but to portray normal Pakistani girls as wearing such dresses, does more disservice to our movies than help accentuate the characters.