Re: Couple stoned to death in Fata
Chalo stoning na sahi..
good case closed.
Tthis thread was talking about stoning that some have been proclaiming as an islamic punishment while you cant find anything in Quran that suggests it. so lets start with this, stoning is not an islamic punishment and thus your previous post is without any merit.
so speaking of simple questions, is stoning an islamic punishment, ...yes or no. Right? :)
Hint- pick 'no'.
what about beheading, eye-for-an-eye, cutting of limbs for theft, flogging etc.... do you support Islamic punishments, or not? Simple question... should have a simple answer. Yes or no. Right? :)
If the rest of the functions of the islamic state are being fulfilled, then yes.
You simply can not have an oppressive state which suppresses ppl, bleeds them dry, and when soemone steals a loaf of bread to feed her family that you chop off her hand. you can not do a half ass job of providing what an islamic state has to provide, but only focus on punishments.
and in the end, Allah is not just Qahaar and Jabbar, but Rehman and Raheem and mghfoor and Kareem. why cant humans be the same way?