Converting out of Islam - in Pakistan

[mukobhai]

Re: Converting out of Islam - in Pakistan

@reduzijuice

Well not even a leaf moves without the permission of Allah, so everything that anyone says happens with His permission?

Revelation to the Prophet was Allah speaking to the Prophet through Jibraeel. However I have never heard of this concept that every single thing that came from the mouth of the Prophet was on Allah’s command (other than Hadith Qudsi - and of course not all hadith are Qudsi).

Do you deny - mukobhai - that there are some hadith which Bukhari rejected because the Isnaad didn’t hold up? Do you deny that there are some hadith which are more highly regarded in terms of veracity than others?

Hadith and Sunnah are not the Word of Allah spoken through Muhammad (other than hadith Qudsi) - that is the Quran - how can you get this basic distinction wrong? The hadith as you mention are words / actions of the Prophet NONE of which were written by the Sahabas until Hazrat Usman encouraged them to do so. You might want to look into the history of how hadiths were recorded - how many were destroyed/discarded because they were contradictory to other hadith/Quran.

Read Quran it is said in the Quran that PROPHET DOESN’T speak on his own he only speak those which ALLAH tells him to speak sir actions of HAZRAT MUHAMMAD SAW were written in the time of HAZRAT MUHAMMAD SAW where did HAZRAT USMAN CAME in this issue ? sir Bukhari and Muslim contain all the authentic Hadees in these two books not a single hadees is which is not authentic and not every one speaks from the order of ALLAH this was only entitled for HAZRAT MUHAMMAD SAW