To keep it simple, i’d suggest use the same concealer for your under eye area AND your highlight. You can try Maybelline’s fit me concealer in the color “medium” however, I think it’ll only be 1 shade lighter, but give it a try. Otherwise try MAC’s prolongwear OR select cover up concealer in NW20. NW 25-30 will be too close to your natural skin color, so it won’t give much of a highlighting effect, you need to use something lighter!