I really dont see if Ali RA being happy/unhappy with Omar RA changes quraan any, did it?
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Fraudz: *
I really dont see if Ali RA being happy/unhappy with Omar RA changes quraan any, did it?
[/QUOTE]
Quran and The Family..thats what Prophet (pbuh&hp) told us to follow according to the sahi books and the shia books..thats what we have been doing since then..the purpose if this thread was to show that Imam Ali (a.s.) married His daughter with the murderer of His beloved Wife (a.s.)..which is ofcourse wrong
I am not all surprised at what the molana said. Did you expect him to say something different?
“..it is funny that you write that Imam Ali (a.s.) was worried that Umar will say no because of her youth.”
Here I was quoting a Sunni source.
"yet in ur earlier post you wrote umar got angry because Imam Ali (a.s.) said no to him "
Here I was quoting hadith from Shia source - hadith from Al-Kafi - Hadith from Imam Jaffer as Sadiq (ra).
Now where’s the flower?
I think I have said enough on this topic I just wanted to show that there is more than enough evidence in Sunni/Shia hadith/History books that this marriage did take place against the evidence in other way round.
In respect of Muharram I’ll take leave from this thread.
and we gave you enough evidence that it was not Ume Kulthum bint Ali (a.s.)..also its all over our hadith books that she was present at Karbala along with her Sister..the night of 9th mohurram is when all the bibi's were preparing their son..so they can go and fight for Imam Hussain (a.s.)..but Bibi Kulthum was sad because she did not have a son who she could sacrifice..but Hazrat Abbas went to her and told her that she has him
its amazing to know that according to some she wasn't even present at karbala and married umar