Compilation of The Quran [Split]

[ravage]

Re: Compilation of The Quran [Split]

@Lajawab

In Islam it is…

no its not. theres no proof for a whole number of things including Allah and the Quran’s veracity except for Allah’s word. That is not proof by any definition of the word.

Whatever was to be revealed, has been revealed and recorded in books in front of the Ummah of the best and the most knowledgable and trustworthy people ever…

even if it were revealed in front of the most corrupt and decadent and immoral and slanderous people ever, IF Allah willed it, what was revealed and recorded would have been kept safe.

It’s not like Christianity where like my post earlier, another version of the gospel pops up and shakes the very foundation of Christianity confusing and confounding the Christians…The antagonist in the whole history of Christianity now suddenly is a protagonist…

Unlike Isa :as: whose Book was compiled after his death, Allah :swt: made sure that the Book Holy Prophet :saw: was given was arranged during his lifetime so that afterwards if anyone came up with changed syntax, words, parables or chronolgy, there would be no way they could tamper with it…

The Quran was not arranged in the Prophet’s lifetime, nor was the compilation issue free. I’d like you to go to Bukhari and actually read the number of sahih ahadis about disputes such as “I heard this verse ended like this but now its not that way”. And so on.

And how can there be any concept of chronology in the Quran to begin with when there were 4 or 5 Surahs being descended at once? Some descending in one day, some descending in months and some descending in years simultaneously?

I can offer you ten different ways to arrangesuch a Quran chronologically. One easy chronological arrangement is to arrange surahs according to when they were completed. One easy chronological arrangement is to arrange surahs according to when they started.