I want to avoid making this into a shia-sunni tussle. However I understand your point of view and it definitely depends on your perception of history. However my understanding about the historical significance regarding the fitnah and then the initial trend of verification of reports is to state that during that time people must have realized that many of the hadith narrators might have personal or political motives seeping through their narrations. Since there was no political strife prior to this event, there was no reason for any personal or political motivation in distorting the ahadith either. I would rather fall into doubt if a hadith which has political implications was narrated by all narrators belonging to the same camp and events during the time of fitnah but this is still not guaranteed.
From your perspective then all ahadith narrated by the Asahaba should be open to scrutiny regardless of their status and allegiance during the time of fitnah. it should not only be those who are against in your perception of history. For the ahadith by these Sahaba have been better scrutinized as compared to the history which tells us of the incidents.