Re: Challenge for Hadeeth Rejectors
I didn't find them any different from yours, may be we need to change our glasses.
[quote]
Your earlier comment is also out of jgnorance of the science of hadeeth. Based on your logic the ten given glad tiding in the time of Prophet SAW would not be considered special in anyway. Which would be completely false. The authentic hadeeth verify their distinction.
[/quote]
Again, I said that I don't take "praising ahadith" as accurate and faith-binding, I respect all sahaba'e karam and its completely between Allah swt and them who goes to Heaven (of course they are way above likes of us) but their such status should not suggest that any hadith attributed to them is completely true and should be taken at their face value.
[quote]
Iconoclaust's response is sufficient for the one who wants to believe based on sound judgement, and insufficient for the one who wants to keep professing their own opinion irregardless of it being just arguments.
WHo collected the hadeeth? how was it reported? Go take a proper course on Hadeeth sciences and you will find out that these are basic questions.
See for a muslim it is imperitive that the basic belief is correct. That is believing in the Devine revealation is not just Quran, it is hadeeth as well. Where does this come from ? The verses of the quran testify to this. Scroll back on the earlier pages and you will find the verses. So just like the current shape (30 juz in a specific order and chapter (surahs) in a specific order are preserved the devine revealation of hadeeth is also preserved.
[/quote]
here you go astray.
[quote]
The only issue is the FAKE hadeeths or so called hadeeths that are being circulated.
[/quote]
How did they come into existence?