Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

It depends on the couple. My wife and I shared almost all our secrets together before getting married. This is because we both wanted to be fully accepted for who we truly are. In other circumstances, the OP's husband might have just simply mentioned it in the past. I mean there are a million possibilities under which she simply might have known if it's something he was doing before so I can't provide every example. But judging by his character, I get the odd feeling that he's not exactly the type to be open and honest about himself.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

No, "porn" is NOT, and I repeat NOT, merely "escapism". You want escapism? Go play World of Warcraft or find another hobby. There are a billion other ways to escape something you're unhappy with. Resorting to porn and allowing an addiction clearly says there's a malfunctioning sexual relationship between a couple unless they both consented to it -- which in this case, it's not the story. So yes, it does in fact take two hands to clap. If you're going to entirely blame someone for something they did in a relationship, then you haven't learned much about responsibility in life yet. The circumstances under which this wouldn't apply might possibly be something as extreme as the partner being a total psychopath who did such a superb job of acting normal for several years and then decided to one day blow the other partner's brains out with an assault rifle. But that's not the case.

Pornography leads to masturbation. Masturbation leads to a heightened sex drive. A heightened sex drive will lead to thoughts of engaging in sexual activity with other people. The thoughts of engaging in sexual activity with other people eventually leads to the next phase of actually committing yourself into performing adultery. Obviously this person has no self-control. Yes, he needs to correct himself but one cannot deny what could have possibly contributed to this in the first place.

I will say it again. A marriage without a healthy sex life is a failed marriage and it falls upon BOTH partners in any marriage to ensure they both remain physically attractive to the other. This is both fair and in my opinion, a moral obligation, since someone has committed their entire life to just you.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

tell him to stop with the porn or you'll tell his mom.

and if he openly checks out other women even when you are with him, either he thinks he is being discreet and failing, or he doesn't really respect you. i say tell his mom about this too.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

great post .. finally someone saying what i said in 2 lines but honestly, a brown woman would never understand this ..

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

No one said Porn addiction is all about "escapism". I said it is not all about sex and fortunately science and a collection of verifiable information otherwise known as "facts" seem to agree with me on this one. Here are a couple of quotes from a study done by Mary Anne Layden, co-director of the Sexual Trauma and Psychopathology Program at the University of Pennsylvania's Center for Cognitive Therapy. Study was presented before senate committee in an effort to censor access via internet. Get ready to be educated.

Paper title: **Internet Porn: Worse Than Crack? **Notice by the title she is comparing internet porn to crack, not some other subversive sexual disorder.

"**most concerning thing to psychological health that I know of existing today." **Notice it says Psychological not just sexual.

"Pornography addicts have a more difficult time recovering from their addiction than **
*cocaine addicts, since coke users can get the drug out of their system, but pornographic *
**images stay in the brain foreve
r" this refers to the Dopamine affect, but in this case memory also has a role to play. So the memory of certain images will produce similar effects and there is no need for an outside substance/chemical/drug. making it really difficult to be sober.

"Pornography really does, unlike other addictions, biologically cause direct release of the **
**most perfect addictive substance,
...which causes release of the naturally occurring opioids. It does what heroin can't do, in **effect" ** I don't see the part where it says the guy needs to be sexually frustrated.

So lets not approach this issue ignorantly and emotionally alone. Her husband has an addiction, and just saying that she's not giving him what he wants is not going to fix anything. Also pornography and masturbation actually leads to depression and feelings of guilt. Allah has created it that way that our nafs tells us we did something wrong and studies prove this. Whereas if you are with your wife, you don't feel that way after consummation of your interaction. So porn addiction, leads to masturbation, leads to depression and decreased self esteem and guilt, which again leads to porn to escape from these feelings and the cycle continues, and what a surprise, a drug addict has the very same cycle.
If you continue to approach this as a sexual problem alone, you will never comprehend and resolve this dilemma. There is nothing that a wife can do that will justify her husband becoming a porn addict, so please don't use that as an excuse and say that it takes 2 to clap. That's just plain dumb. By that logic, every young man who is not married (and is therefore sexually frustrated since biologically he is ready all the time) should become a porn addict because he is sexually frustrated.

Sure, the sister can help him by taking better care of herself and not being a typical desi wife. Dressing a certain way. Being more aggressive and talkative during intimacy etc. Asking him what he wants her to wear, dancing or doing other similar things for him ( All are allowed between spouses in Islam) Desi wives are very passive when it comes to these things, although they can be as aggressive as a bear when it comes to complaining and whining. So use some of that nagging energy during intimacy. And remember, it's not your fault!

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

Wow, people really can write paragraphs on a random internet forum about this subject.

Hey wifey, what happened? Did you backhanded your husband on the head or are you another one of roti bahoo stories now like a pakistani drama?

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

yur huzban iz jerk.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

None of us will look beautiful forever...one day you'll all look like prunes.

No matter how hard you workout, your eyes will develop bags under them, you won't be able to do acrobats in bed and gravity will all of a sudden become a very evil reality :(

What happens then? Is it okay to watch porn then?

And for people who said you should have talked about this before marriage...if he was wearing a name tag saying "avid porn watcher" do you think she would have married him?

I don't think there is a right or wrong answer here for the OP. She really needs to figure out how much this means to her and then make a move. If she loves her husband, she should go for counseling and therapy. Maybe with proper coaching, he can be better.

Whatever the future holds, you cannot give up without trying your hardest.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

husband only read last line.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

Homesick, I agree with your new post a lot from. Had you said that to start off with, there wouldn't have been confusion. Look at what you said for example:

Therefore the implication, whether intentional or unintentional, behind what you said is that his addiction doesn't have any sexual connections to him watching porn.

However, I asked a question about why he resorted to watching porn in the first place. And then I asked if this was a habit he already had before their marriage. If the latter were true (he was already watching porn before marriage), then you'd be spot on. Otherwise, we'd have to go back to my post and then ask the questions I did such as, "What led him to feel the need to watch porn in the first place?" You're merely discussing the withdrawal effects of porn addiction. Yes, he needs help whether it be from a Muslim psychiatrist or an Islamic marriage counselor, however, the circumstances need to be looked into further as you also touched on.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

lmaooooo

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

lol thank you.. instead of writing page long paragraphs about pornography and the wife being inadequate.

-there's two issues here (pornography and checking other women out)...he continues to check out women (not one, two, three...but every young/pretty girl)...i understand as human beings we're attracted to physicality of the opposite gender but as muslims you should remember that God placed limits on you...No muslim man is allowed to check out every woman on the planet...just the four he's allowed to marry...so that being said..i'm sure he's surpassed his limit.

-lots of guys watch porn-fact. they're sinning...u have to realize its not ur fault that he continues to/chooses to sin...if he's that fed up with the wife, why doesnt he be a man in other ways...divorce her and find another woman that fulfills his fantasies...err no he'd rather continue doing it the haram way. you ppl are blaming everyone/everything but the person committing zina.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

No, it's not okay then but then this is venturing into other territory. There's no reason for them to be having these issues in their early years of marriage. My advice would've been different ahd they been much older. Regardless, no one ever said having a great sex life with your partner is the only key to a happy marriage. You're taking it way out of context.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

Watching porn once in a while is understandable but everyday - not so much. Porn is highly addictive and once addicted, it has a major impact on your ability to have a healthy and satisfying sex life even with a cherished partner.

Good news is that there's much help available out there for those that are willing to help themselves. From your post, it doesn't sound like he's too concerned about quitting this habit. The notion that he isn't too concerned is a lot more concerning. It could be because you've concealed this aspect for him so gracefully for three years (if posting anonymously online is the only sharing you've done). If you do decide to leave him, something to consider is will you expose this side of him to others including family and friends or will you cite other 'irreconcilable differences'. That will make a significant impact on how the community judges your decision.

It's really interesting how you describe him as a shy guy who wouldn't actually carry out verbal or physical flirtation but definitely outwardly exhibits signs of wanting to. Porn can also make certain things much less significant to carry out. So the people that are saying it's all good because he isn't cheating on you, you should really consider the change you've seen in him for the last three years - has his behaviour become more or less sexually pronounced. Then think about the next three years.

Lastly, no one here should be dictating whether this is a significant enough or insignificant reason for leaving him because only you can answer that question as per your own moral code and inner values.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

He needs to see a doctor, this attitude in a grown man is not normal.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

You might think so from a guy's perspective which is his half of the marriage. What about the woman's perspective? Her side of things?

Not every woman is 1000% secure or able to rationalize every thing away. Everyone has their personal issues, battles and insecurities. For a woman, knowing her husband is interested in only her is important...more important than many things. Its not possible for her to feel a-okay (or anyone for that matter) with her husband constantly watching porn.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

[quote]
No muslim man is allowed to check out every woman on the planet...just the four he's allowed to marry...so that being said..i'm sure he's surpassed his limit.
[/quote]
I get it that watching other women overtly is not good, but seriously this came out WAAAAY wrong. Only watching the four that he marries? Even islam allows you to talk to girls before marriage, but I never saw a limit of just one or 4 as in this case and you are cut off from looking at girls for the rest of your life. Please don't ridicule Islam like this. As for the gravity doing its work on the female body, the couple is married like 3 years and unless they are old, then I don't even know how this is relevant. Both men and women check each other out, but the clever ones do it on the sly.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

^ This.

Please stop talking!!! Before you decide to write creative bull**** on a public forum, please take a moment to think what if this was happening to your sister, daughter, best friend, or worst, yourself. Would you have given the same "advice" then?

"...'just because' he watches porn?" JUST BECAUSE??? Sharam se doob marne ka maqaam hai. Yeh muslim community ka haal hai.

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

i said checking out random women all the time is haram...you can only check out your wives (thats four women at a time...yes?)
i didnt say talking to them is haram..

Re: Caught my Husband Watching Porn For the Past 3 Years

with all due respect people, i thought zina can be committed through eyes, ears and hands (and whatever other organ of the body also)

i dont know why the muslim community is beginning to accept men watching porn as the norm/something unavoidable/natural for men to do.