I wasn’t around then so I read some of that thread and some of the responses are appalling. An astonishingly high percentage of the replies are along the lines of “Well, he shouldn’t have killed her but she deserved it!”. The implication is if he did something less than kill her to punish her, such as beat her severely it would have been okay. She “deserved” punishment for not wearing a scarf (did her killer cover his head? We know the answer…)? I thought there is no compulsion in Islam yet many of the replies are calling for compulsion on a minor issue such as whether 50% of the population should cover its hair (because the assumption is much of the other 50% can’t handle seeing hair. Perversely under this thinking it is the woman’s fault for what any man may do)?