Can someone please substantiate/confirm

[psyah]

Re: Can someone please substantiate/confirm

@vroom

Well for one you said you believed the shadow did appear like normal, yet these Hadiths say it did not

“The shadow of the Prophet [SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam] could not be seen in the brightness of the sun, nor in moonlight”.

"The Messenger of Allah had no shadow, not while standing in the sun, but the brilliance of his light (nur) surpassed the rays of the sun; nor while sitting before a burning light, but his luminous light excelled the lustre of the light".

“Allah Almighty does not let your shadow fall on the ground, so that no foot of man can fall on it”

“This is also a unique feature of the Prophet [SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam] that his shadow did not touch the ground, because he was light (*nur), and when he used to walk in the sunshine his shadow could not be seen.”

*The Urdu was closer to these narrations?]

and the scholars have not said ‘‘sometimes’’ either, there is something that we are missing or have gained.

So we are forced to interpret the Hadith that refer to him (SAW) having a shadow right? Or can it be said that a shadow was present in very rare circumstances?

One of the references that states the shadow of RasoolAllah (SAW) does so through a vision of RasoolAllah (SAW) narrated by him himself … The other narrations of there not being a shadow are describing him, but from the narrator’s perspective not really his own words, which could mean they are narrating perspective rather than scientific reality.