Can someone please substantiate/confirm

Re: Can someone please substantiate/confirm

Peace Muzna,

Brother Ibn Sadique answered in detail. I’ll just answer in general not making it a very long post. An article was published in a local newspaper issued in the State of Kuwait, and I quote:

"The entire people of Ahlehadith agreed that the hadith (as extracted in Image of OP’s post as well as quoted by brother TLK [fake hadiths]) is a lie and baseless. It was broght by Shaikh Mohyuddin bin Arbi Albatani (known for Aqeedatul Halool val Ietihad), who died in the seventh century, without any supports/authentications. Peoples in the seventh century were not aware of such hadith if narrated in books of the Muslims and later on it is used as philosophical and mystical terms with similar terminology of refuted books of Ismailies, actually who were studied from Ibn-Arbi and taken lessen of Greek Idolatry philosophy.

Later on in the tenth century some scholars attributed it to Abdul Razzaq without mentioning his complete name nor mentioning about him in any book. Those who came after him (after Abdul Razzaq) thought he is actually a famous narrators Iman Hafiz Abdulrazaq bin Hamam Al-San’ani who died in 211 H. His book was published but the narration wasn’t in there. [Note: Abdul Razzaq and Imam Hafiz Abdulrazaq bin Hamam Al’San’ani are two different character].

When some extremist didn’t find and supportive to these sayings (in OP’s image), they allegedly linked it to to the author Imam AbdulrRazaq by saying it was missing manuscript and they added it in a new edition (while printing his book) and presented it to 'Isa bin Maneh Al-Hamiri who presented it to ‘Mahmood Saeed Mamdoh’, who believed in it.

Those who refuted it are: Suyuti, Jamal Al Qasimi, Mohammed Rashid Rida, Ibn Baaz, Albanian, Mohammed Ahmed bin Abdul Qadir Shanqeeti, Mohamed Tahar Ashour, and Ahmed Abdullah along with many others.

Imam Abdulrazaq was innocent and had nothing to do with such sayings.

Almighty Allah knows best.