crankthatskunk , you are scaring me with your knowledge man. You know a lot more than i do man. wow ! stop scaring me. What do i do so that you stop exposing us ? money would do ? :D
I am not going to write paragraphs after paragraphs to prove my stance. However, what I am going to do is to put it in point form for you as well as other readers to have a better understanding of what I am talking about.
- Being a shadow of someone is and should not be something that you should not be able to understand. Being a shadow of someone is to show respect. Shadow never comes into being without someone giving it off. Also, shadow is always on the ground and does exactly what a person does. Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (AS) was a shadow of Muhammad PBUH just exactly in that sense. He(AS) used to follow exactly what His master (PBUH) used to follow. This is why He says that whatever level from Allah he got was achieved because of continuous obedience to His master , the holiest prophet Muhammad PBUH.
- If Quran proves Isa AS's death then all hadith mentioning Isa (AS) is NOT bogus and should not be discarded. Why you would ask ? It is because Isa AS is the title given to Imam Muhammad Mahdi by Prophet Muhammad PBUH. There are mutawatir ahadith mentioning His second coming which cannot be discarded. So, who is Isa AS mentioned in various ahadith if His death has been proved from Quran ? now thats the question.. dont you think ? You can quote me here and we will discuss on this regard anytime, but theres no point me explaining my own question if you're not willing to read/learn.
- To put it simply, yes i am avoiding the question raised by you because they make no sense whatsoever. You know why? because the thing that we both agree upon is the need of a reformer after Muhammad PBUH. You people make a nabi (isa AS) an ummati of Muhammad PBUH , while Ahmadis make **ummati of Muhammad PBUH **as the nabi. IF our whole belief was off , then you're more then welcome to write blog after blog , and cant shake the beliefs of Ahmadis proven by Quran and ahadith.
- Since you agreed that there have been Muslims believing in Isa AS's death, you did not mention did they discard Isa AS's related Ahadith?
- Theres no concept of re-incarnation in Islam , however there is a concept of giving titles. Hazrat Yahya (AS) was given the title of Hazrat Elijah (AS).
- Your belief of Isa (AS) needs to be discussed first because if it is not discussed , will lead you to think Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (AS) is the 're-incarnation' of Isa (AS), which is un-islamic, and a false accusation.
Let me ask you something man. Why are you a believer of Islam ? What do you see in Muhammad PBUH ? why dont other people see the same thing in Prophet Muhammad PBUH's teaching ? Why do they reject ?
You will never accept Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (AS) as the Imam Mahdi and the promised Messiah until and unless your other beliefs are changed. i.e: your view on khatam e naboowat , Isa AS's death. Keep bringing on your useless questions.