please dont discuss wasi shah in this thread…i like him as a writer but he is not a poet… us jaisi azad nazmain koi tom dec harry bhi likh sakta hai , so … baqi aap samjhdaar hain
please dont discuss wasi shah in this thread...i like him as a writer but he is not a poet... us jaisi azad nazmain koi tom dec harry bhi likh sakta hai , so .... baqi aap samjhdaar hain
Really. Lets agree to disagree. Khuda jisse izzat deta hai, uss main kuch gunn hote hain.. nahin to Tom Dick Herry Pakistan main bhi boht aur India main bhi beshumar hain
Really. Lets agree to disagree. Khuda jisse izzat deta hai, uss main kuch gunn hote hain.. nahin to Tom Dick Herry Pakistan main bhi boht aur India main bhi beshumar hain
Khuda jisay chahata hai izzat deta hai..is say mujhay inkaar nai...lakin agar wo mashoor hai tu is ka matlab yeh nai k woo shair bhi acha hai...or mashoor woo dramay say ziayda howa tha, drama nikal doo ... or phir us k baad us ki book market may lay jaoo...may bhi dekhta kitnay loag us ko parhtay..or wasey bhi mummy dady lovers ko aisi he shairi appeal karti hai...i mean no offence to any one...but the fact is that jis shairi k aik aik lafaz may darya nai woo shairi shairi nai....nasar ko azad nazam bana dena bara karnama nai...
tu nay dewana banaya tu may dewana bana...
abb mujhay hosh ki dunia may tamasha na bana...
is jaisa aik shair bhi wasi shah ki shairi say dhond k laa doo...aik aik lafaz is shair ka samundar hai....
:mirch: miyan saab… Parveen Shakir ke baad nae likhne walon main agar kisi ko sab se ziada gaya gaya hai to wo Wasi Shah hai.. Azad Nazm main bhi agar taranum ho tab hi wo gai ja sakti hai…
baqi ke liye itna hi kahoon ga: Pasand apni apni
There is compartmentalisation in Poetry when liking and disliking comes into field. A new writer may write something that can attract people more than old poets
but it doesn’t mean woo acha poet bhi hoooo…aap achay achay shairon say poch lain…k wasi shah ki shairi ka kiya muqaam hai…idar tu EYE to EYE mashoor ho jata hai…mashoori ki baat chorain…personal liking disliking to bhi chorain…shairi k standards pay he us ki shairi jaanch lain…
jab kisi se Allah waste ka ber ho jae to koi daleel kaam nahin aati.. so this topic is closed at my end. aap Wasi Shah ko khat likh ke apne tahafuzaat ka izhar kar len :cobra:
bhai ji Allah wastay ka bair hota tu us ki writing skills ki tareef karta?..lakin poetry…yahan aap ki baat manana mushkil hai…daleel tu may nay bhi dee hai…eye to eye ki…kiya abb woo reeshma say bara singer hai? aisay tu nai hota na…hamari baat ko bhi kuch wazan daien…aisay na karain…