Which do you prefer? I used to apply green and black only. Until I discovered how amazing the brown one looks 
Brown eye pencil vs black
Black One :@:
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
I smudge the brown pencil, then apply black liquid liner very thinly on top.
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
I actually prefer brown or grey over black. Often I find black to be a bit harsh. But I also have green and purples and love wearing those too as they both compliment brown eyes/desi skin tone.
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
I wear brown liner mostly during daytime for more of a softer look; and for evenings quiet often if I have time I apply the brown underneath the black liner to give more of a defined look to the eyes! but all in all can't go wrong with any colours; I love em all :)
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
I use green and black.
I actually prefer brown or grey over black. Often I find black to be a bit harsh. But I also have green and purples and love wearing those too as they both compliment brown eyes/desi skin tone.
What grey shade you use? And how about the brand? Thinking to get grey and brown this time.
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
What grey shade you use? And how about the brand? Thinking to get grey and brown this time.
Grey:
MAC Industry
Bobby Brown Graphite Shimmer Ink (Gel liner)
Browns:
MAC Stubborn Brown
Tarte Moonstone Brown
Bobby Brown Sepia Ink (Gel liner)
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
I lovvve brown eyeliners...pencils that can be smudged. Urban Decay makes a great one. Its soft and blends beautifully.
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
I feel like brown (or any other color for that matter) never shows up on me or gives me that oomph I want. :( But I get sick of black......
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
I recently began loving brown too!! if not, im a hardcore black or green eyeliner user with some blue eyeliner usage some times.
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
I use brown for the day and a black for evenings. Sara, if you use a good eye-base then the black really shows-up! MAC Paint pots, NYX eye-base in white work well.
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
Brown.
Paheli, I feel like the BB gel liner is too light, it doesn't show up like it should. Unless you use it with black eye liner in your eyes with the gel on top?
Re: Brown eye pencil vs black
I use brown on my lower lid and black on my uppler lid. I mostly use black to tight line and line the waterline though, when I do, which is mostly for going out. My favourite brown is 8pm by Bare Escentuals.. Its like a black coffee kind of colour, a blackened brown.