Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

I’ve been out of the country and studying at university for the past 8 months. Came home to visit my family this summer, and I’m leaving in 2 weeks. 2 days ago, my family and I were told something dreadful by my 5 and 8-year old sisters. My 14-year old brother has sexually abused them the past few months. He has done it on multiple occasions, and threatened them so they wouldn’t tell anyone in the house (naturally, since he wouldn’t want to get caught). The last time he did it was nearly 4 months ago. The secrets all came out.

This caught us all off-guard, and the house has been in chaos ever since. My father, already displeased with my brother since he didn’t put effort into his studies, says he no longer cares what happens to him. My mother certainly dislikes him, but she still speaks with him time to time, and gets upset whenever my father kicks him out of the house. She wants him to be sent to some sort of hostel, away from the house. Doesn’t like the idea of “kicking him out”. Would this fix problems? I doubt it. The third sister hates him. I definitely despised what he did, but it shows he’s in shock and embarrassed. I don’t want him to be shunned completely, I want him to fix himself. Yes what he did was hideous, and he has left scars on my sisters, but does this mean that the only plausible solution is to hate him forever? He’s 14, supposed to be able to think for himself, but he didn’t. What now though? Should he be completely ignored, left to himself, and hated by everyone? It’s like everyone is taking the easy way out, and it’s hard to watch my only brother in this state. I wonder what’s going through HIS mind. How is HE taking the incident? My family has to be realistic here, even though this is a very delicate matter. You can’t just kill him.

My brother has some major social issues. You could say he gets along with people, but all his friends are years younger than him. The older kids he has known are among the loafer type, who spend their day on a cell phone and don’t care much for their future. He hasn’t been associated with many of these older kids, but what do I know? I haven’t given him the time an older brother should have. I kept to myself, locked in the room with my computer for hours. Only occasionally would I come out and spend time with him. What gets him in trouble is his attitude towards elders. If he does something wrong, he will attempt to justify it even though everyone says he’s guilty. He doesn’t treat his teachers as he should, and thinks he deserves the same level of respect as them. He will not shut up when he should.

I’m not too familiar with how things work in Pakistan, but I’ve thought about getting him set up with a Psychiatrist, at least until I’m gone. I don’t know where to begin though. My family and I had been out of the country for a major part of my childhood, and during my time here, I didn’t go out much. Really, right now I’m the only one who can prevent any drastic action from my father’s side.

It’s difficult to watch my family being torn apart. Any constructive input is appreciated.

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Take him to a therapist. Also take your sisters as they must be suffering through trauma.

My prayers are with you and your family. This must be an extremely difficult time for all of you. I don’t even know what advice to give. Just that your mom and dad need to be very watchful. They have three kids to raise who are emotionally and psychologically at a very very vulnerable stage.

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Astagfirullah…

Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Hi there

I’m really sorry to hear what you’re going through, this is certainly a difficult issue and must be handled with care. You should definitely take your brother to a psychiatrist on his own to try and find out what his issue is and also ur sisters need help to get through this. I’m a psychiatrist myself and work mostly with youths so sadly I’ve seen issues like this more often than I would have liked. Feel free to pm me for more info :slight_smile:

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Wow. Your brother needs to face punishment for his criminal behavior and the lifelong effects it is going to have on your sisters. He should have been reported to the police, and whatever sexual rehabilitation program they would have put him in is what would help him. Honestly, who cares what he’s thinking??? He’s a CRIMINAL. I find it very unfair to keep him around the sisters. Would anyone think its normal for a person to be forced to live with their rapist? Just because he’s the brother, it’s different? They should not be subject to the fear of him doing it again and living with someone who has harmed them. Everyday would be a constant reminder and it is extremely emotionally damaging on them since it came from a family member and at such a young age. In all of this, what is being done to help the sisters? You havent mentioned anything about them or what you feel for them… how come? At the very least, they definitely should be put into therapy.

As for the brother, you reap what you sow. There’s no excuse for his behavior. He’s 14, he knows right from wrong. PERIOD.

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

your parents must call police and he needs to be put behind bars in order to save other girls who might fall victim at his hands…send him off to solitary confinement and throw the key away…the real punishment will come in the hereafter. He doesn’t deserve any sympathy from anyone!

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Absolutely! I’m shocked and horrified at the sympathy that is coming for him… those 2 girls are BABIES STILL… 5 and 8… victims of sexual abuse never really heal from what they’ve gone through. He has damaged them and ruined their lives, and here the older brother is just concerned for what he’s feeling?! Unbelievable. Every action has its consequences, the brother deserves to be KICKED OUT, ARRESTED, SHUNNED AND HATED. DISGUSTING!!!

Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Yahhh subahanAllah!! I wish I had not read this thread, especially during this blessed month of Ramadan. So so disturbing, disgusting, I’m finding it hard to comprehend… May Allah grant your sisters with strength and the ability to forget!! May their lives be happy and prosperous.

I have two daughters and I find it very disturbing when I read information like this. May Allah protect all our daughters and sisters, ameen.

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

In a way he is distraught at how, the jackass ie his brother has lost the respect of everyone, for LIFE. Which is understandable so lets not jump down this throat.

As for the OP, psychiatrist would be needed here definitely at the very least. This behavior would likely manifest into something more terrible. What if he goes out and rapes a woman when he’s more older and ruins another family? It needs to be stopped

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

^ I *guess. *I dunno… I don’t like the wording of how he’s saying its hard to watch his brother in this state… umm sorry last person whose state is of any concern is the criminal’s.

Everyone should focus on the girls. There should be a zero tolerance policy towards and no sympathy for people who sexually molest others, especially children.

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

His brother is just 14…his actions are screaming for help.

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

My “sympathy” towards him isn’t causing me to ignore what he has done. Shunning him won’t fix anything. Taking him to the police here won’t fix anything, they’re going to beat him to death. He’s 14, he is at a critical stage. He needs help, hating him is going to turn him into a despicable human being, who might turn into a criminal in his future. I would take him to a sex rehab. center, but I can’t find any here. These incidents are heard of in the country, but it’s difficult to find psychological treatment for the predators.

It’s the same thing with the younger sisters. I don’t know where to begin asking for therapy. I’ve spoken to them, but it’s not enough. My role as a brother has a different impact, I know. The parents are unwilling to help me look for a psychiatrist, so I’m stuck alone. Plus, I leave soon. I’m at a total loss… and running away from the problem isn’t an option I want to take.

Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

For those of you saying he should be locked up, beaten etc etc u forget that he is only 14! There is no indication here of his state of mind, what if he’s not like an average 14 year old? Shunning him will only make the whole situation worse. OP I suggest you take him to a normal doctor and ask them to refer you to a psychiatrist they will definitely recommend a specialist, you don’t even have to explain what’s happened just ask them fr help as ur right in some places it’s difficult to access the help you need

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Will do so today, thank you very much.

If you are in lahore, there are a couple of child psychiatrists here.

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Befriend him and see what else is going on with his life, 14 is a young/ vulnerable age and easily influenced. He needs help/guidance. Be in his life before he completely drifts away from everyone

And bring the girls to a health check-up

and ask him, is he shock and embarrass because the secret is out or because of his actions? What is to be done now?

Prayers with you all

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Firstly don’t be too melodramatic. A few people I have known and love have had abuse so I know what a terrifying thing it is. Secondly that criminal happens to be his baby brother, a brother who has just chucked his life and respect away FOREVER. Obviously he will feel distraught for him too. Its such a simple concept that you’re not able to grasp. :smack: His sisters just got abused too, hence I am surprised and saddened he, the OP, had to defend himself to you.

Lets not forget the 14 year old is a CHILD too. A criminal child but a child nonetheless. How many families of criminals do you see shunning and rejecting them? I’ve seen none. Because family is family.

In a way the OP has had his sisters AND brother’s innocence taken away forever. I don’t know about you but to find him distraught about both people is not only understandable but expected.

Re: Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

Befriending him is my intention, but he’s making it harder for me. We haven’t spoken for days, and just today he made me yell at him for trying to order his sisters around again, and not listening to his mother when he should have.

I have to let him know that his family will “not” despise him, PROVIDED that he changes himself. The two younger ones had no respect for him (rightly so), but I told them, that if he ever changes and no longer seems like a threat, it’s okay to consider his actions and efforts in good will. Not happening anytime soon though. Heading to a psychiatrist seems to be when I’ll initiate conversation with him.

More importantly, I have to somehow ensure my father will change his attitude when I’m gone to university again. Kicking him out of the house for a few hours when he’s displeased isn’t right. It completely ignores the problem.

Brother has had sexual contact with sisters - what now?

You’re right OP ignoring the problem is not the right way to go, it is upto u to start getting ur siblings the help they need, shunning him may lead him into deeper trouble as u don’t know what he’s doing out of the house or what he might get into! Clearly there are underlying issues here someone needs to get to the bottom of it, from my experience I hve hope that u and ur family will come through this as he is still so young himself and getting help for ur sisters now rather than just letting them deal with it will benefit them greatly! I really do think there is something else wrong here to have caused this to happen, my prayers are with u n ur family.