Re: Britney wants to embrace Islam
Psyah
I read your posts with great interest normally and did so above too.
May be it is a language thing but what you wrotE does sound not just judgemental but well beyond that, to the point of passing sentence. You wrote "nobody should take shahada from her until bla bla". That is a clear implication that you have judged her untrustworthy and passed a sentence that she needs to further prove before you will admit her.
Similarly elsewhere you say normally the b st of non-muslims usually convert and become best of muslims. If that is the epidemy of generalized judgemental attitude, I don't know what else is.
You like everyone else is entitled to your views ofcourse but as I have mentioned in the past, your great knowledge and piety actually assigns responsibiilities to you (IMO) and therefore saying one thing and doing another is a deeper disappointment coming from you than others. (Sorry for a personal note there).
Now, why exactly can't we let BS do what she want w.o doubting? If you consider sin a disease and islam a cure, isn't it. In order that the sick seek the remedy and not the healthy?
Finally, the irony is striking. There's a thread current where people are pushing for a husband to convert just so the marriage to a converted wife can be valid (or the wedlock is gone they claims). And here yiou are taking a different stand.
When did hypocracy become a pillar for the self appointed trustees of islam?