Brelvi and Deobandi fiqh (Do we need them?)

[hareem01]

@TLK

Just to clarify, when Barelvi hazraat say that Prophet is/was made out of noor, they are not speaking metaphorically. They are talking about the real life substance that he was created out of.

There is a well known rivayat that became popular because of this very belief: the rivayat that Prophet did not have a shadow. Its just amazing the percentage of awaam that believes in it. This rivayat did not came out of any metaphorical belief but a real life belief.

There is also a weak hadith that says that Allah created all the Prophets with noor.

Because these ahadith are weak we can’t be sure about them 100% nor we can make our aqidah based on these weak ahadith, but also we can’t call Brelwis wrong for this.