Brelvi and Deobandi fiqh (Do we need them?)

[cricketplaya]

@diwana

I think you have been avoiding the core of the question in other thread and this one. These madhabs were created by people by following imams who never themselves wanted this way.

And these imams were born after the prophet SAW.

The prophet SAW with all the wisdom and knowledge and recommendations, never one said to follow anyone after him like a madhab.

His SAW last sermon said two things to follow. And hope you know. What they are.

It is the duty of EVERYONE to search what is in those two items which was advised to be followed.

Not leaving the responsibility to any aalim only. I said ‘only’ here for a reason.

That is the biggest problem with not only muslims but people of other religion too. They follow human being like superior being ‘blindly’ out of shear laziness and find excuse of lack of knowledge.

I am sorry, we are again going to the topic I started. I will stop here. If you wish and answer in other thread. or if you do not then that is fine too.

Again we’re going in circles

Allah has said in Quran, go to the people of knowledge. I see no harm in going to the people of knowledge, Allah knows best for us. That is why it is advised, throughout history to have a teacher. For anything in this world, you need a teacher. You want to become a physicist, you can read all the books in this world and still not be able to grasp the knowledge. You need a teacher. That is why we have the 4 madhabs (in reality they are 1 since they all follow the 2 sources), now Prophet SAW is not here to tell us. Where do we go? Do we start reading and interpreting ourselves or do we go to the people of knowledge? Again, there is no harm in learning, all scholars throughout history have promoted learning but we should differentiate between learning and deriving rulings. The latter only leads people astray.