I am neither defensive nor insulting MS u posted u're views I posted mine... and everyone has the right to do so. U're research is scientific mine is thru several scholars and real life experiences. Do u disagree that the Prophet was affected by it? Do u disagree that the 2 Surahs were sent after the Prophet suffered? Do u disagree that magic is used times over in the Quran and Allah himself has given a verse to His people to seek protection from "the blower on knots and from the envious one when he envies" if there was no such thing as magic..wud Allah swt send down these Surah's?
Anyway, this discussion has become rathar monotonous. For those that want to blv it doesn't exist please do. Those that blv it does, please do.