Asif2000: psychiatric problems, perhaps, a more influence from the Western Society. But if you really understand and research Sihr/Black Magic, you will insha'Allah understand....trust me, I like you thought the same, but was proven wrong. A man was treated for severe epilepsy through Ruqaya (recitations of the Quran). During Prophet Mohammad (SAW) time a man was bitten by a snake, and a Shruqh recited Surah Al-Fatiha over it, by placing his hand, and was cured. I honestly believe that there is no anti-depressant/ SSRI stronger than the Quran. And as a doctorate, the psychological medical conditions you are referring to are more theoretical than we have been influenced to believe. Neurochemistry and biochemical (i.e. dopamine system) is all influenced psychologically, and what is more influential on your mental state than the Quran? ... Subhan'Allah, I myself am learning a lot and day by day get more fascinated...
Maybe you misunderstood me. Let me try again. Quran is greater than all medications and remedies to treat any medical condition. No questions there.
What I was suggesting was more along the lines of a combination approach. Consider the medications as a blessing from Allah. After all, Quran and Hadees teache you to learn ILM and ILM is what brought about the medications for illness.
If you say that recitation of Quran can ONLY treat black magic, then you are wrong my friend. My point, which you ignored, was that by reciting Quran, mastanamalik may be treating/curing a mental illness, not black magic. Again, Black Magic exists but how do we know for sure that is what he is experiencing. He has been hallucinating during his illness and this may still be nothing but hallucinating.