Re: Bida'a...
brother i actually replied with a general post about what Ahmad G was stating as he is in the past quoted weak hadiths and accused many shaykhs of things they are free of AND quoted hadiths out of context.
[QUOTE]
all-non-arab-do-'bidah'
all-arab-do-no-bidah
because-arabs-are-holy
[/QUOTE]
That is not true becos even the arabs themselves(not all) do bidah!
Holy is the one who adheres to the Qur'aan and Sunnaah alone!
i have read the contens and it ios the same as b4 which i have heard many times with people trying to justify a "good bidah".
Before giving points on what is good and what is bad we have to start at the foundations which Is Bidah, can it be good?
NO WAY!