Bida'a...

[Code_Red]

Re: Bida’a…

@Lajawab

Azaan is a call to prayer…It is not a part of faith…In its absence the practice of Islam is neither affected nor changed…Hence it can not be classified as a Bida’a…Plus, it was approved by the Holy Prophet :saw:…

A’raaf were added for the benefit of non-Arabic speakers otherwise you or me would not know how to pronounce words in the Quran…There are still Quran in Saudi Arabia like the Kufi script Quran which has no A’raaf…Its introduction does not alter the practices of Islam hence it is not a Bida’a…

Bida’a means introducing something as a practice in Islam which is neither perscribed in the Quran or practiced in the Sunnah…Like wearing black in Muharram which is neither in the Quran nor the Sunnah…Yet, it’s practice usually performed in the name of showing respect…

Where is wearing black as a sign of respect to anyone perscribed anywhere? Hence, it is a practice introduced in Islam and hence it is a Bida’a…

And for those that support it saying it’s quite harmless, well, as Mirza Ruswa said in the other thread, the supporting of sin is sometimes worse than the sin itself…

It’s just a caution…

Brother Lajawab and Jan Leva !
Please read carefully.

Lajawab since according to you Azaan (something very basic and vital part of Muslim society, and on this very issue there are recorded incidents of voilence and killing of innocent muslim around the world ) is not part of faith. fine !

But then how on earth somehting as trival as wearing black or observing muharam has become part of faith ? Is showing respect against the sunnah ? prove it.

You have no objection on innovation in Azaan ( I believe it was done during the caliphate of Hazrat Umar, if prophet had approved it then there is no question of biddah. Correct me if i am wrong ) then why object people who are wearing black to remeber darkest part of their history ??

Double standard or what !

Now Come to putting Aa’raab on quranic text.
Who has done it ? Hajaj bin yousuf.
Was he a sahabi ? No ! he was a butcher, a tyrant who has killed thousands fo innocent muslim without any reason !

A quote

An Ummayyad leader once stated that if all the nations brought their most tyrannical and evil rulers, the Muslims would only need to bring al-Hajjaj to surpass the rest of the world’s murderous rulers in evil.

And we are following a bid’ah of such a person ! Sub’haan Allah !

And whoever says that Aaraabs were added for simplification
My question : Arabic is one of the major language of this planet, And we find it written on everything from TV manuals, preserved food, grocery products and everywhere. They use no Aa’raab ! No where you will see these !

You see them as tool for simplification, because it was done by some Holy Arabi guy, I see them as a bid’ah which made things complicated. I support my argument by the fact that Arabic written in every part of world is Not supported by these Aa’raabs If more than billion people can read them perfectly than why not Quran ?