Re: Baree vs. Jehez
If I was to give a gift to someone who means alot to me, I would buy them what they would love and want to use/wear. I wouldn't just go to a dollar store and get the crappiest thing I can find. The thoughts put into a gift shows how much you care. Im sure most of us aren't needy or greedy, and Alhumdulillah can afford pretty much anything we want (okay maybe not everything but alot of things) and don't need to depend on our mothers in law to give them to us. Like I mentioned before in my post, I wouldn't be angry but a bit disappointed. Honestly, Im buying my own stuff for jahez, my parents will get me anything I want and so will my husband. I don't have expectations from my inlaws.. the 7 or 10 or whatever number of clothes in baree aren't gonna change my life, the gold set for me isn't gonna make me a millionaire, the makeup gifts aren't gonna make my dresser compete with a mac store. But it's not necessary that every girl should think that way. This may not be your right but it is a tradition at weddings, it's a HUGE part of our culture. Why would we have gift exchanging if it didn't have a meaning attached to it? It's sad that people have turned it into a business by demanding stuff but the important idea of a baree is to give gifts to the girl who is about to enter your family. And giving crappy stuff doesn't speak very highly about the intentions.
I don't buy this whole crap about oh look at the bigger picture (that's just a lame excuse for ignoring what's going on) or oh yeah your mil's being cheap in an obvious way but don't worry about it because she means well. Im sure there are MILs who don't do it on purpose and just have bad taste to begin with but there ARE those who just buy stuff because they HAVE to and not because they want to. I have seen the nicest of MILs going shopping and buying everything with so much love.. my bahu will like this or I want to give my bahu the prettiest stuff.
It's not just about wanting stuff but rather the sentiment attached to the baree.