Banning Non Muslims in Makkah

[X2]

Re: Banning Non Muslims in Makkah

@Ibn_Sadique

X2 Your knowledge and observational skills are impressively dazzling! I hope next time you read with your eyes open wide!

I Appreciate your acknowledgment of my superior knowledge and observation skills..

@Ibn_Sadique

X2 I hope next time you read with your eyes open wide!

I do each time, so lets do a demo of that..

@Ibn_Sadique

I was just responding to brother kchughtai – that his uncle was allowed to pray in a church.

You fixed nothing as nothing was broken. There was no argument – you just jumped in

its a discussion forum, I added to the discussion. I simply added that his uncle would have been able to visit…

@Ibn_Sadique

Allowing to someone to visit Vatican and letting him/her to pray in it are two different issues.

Indeed they are…and from the start my point was about a ‘visit’ .. looks like someone did need to read with eyes open.

Lets see my original post

@X2

but he was able to visit…

see the word visit…open your eyes a little..does it say pray? ..no? ..good.
repeat after me ‘visit’

@Ibn_Sadique

^ the Holy of Holies – The Vatican???

Or just any church?

Lets see your response, you don’t clarify you are talking about praying.
let me open my eyes more…ummmm no. don’t see the word pray.

so what was my response

@X2

I meant that he would be able to visit the Vatican.
I have on several occasions. I studied in Rome and visited the Vatican fairly frequently since it was just a small detour on my walk from campus to my flat.

oh yes, I explained that visiting vatican is fine. again repeat after me ‘visit’
open your eyes just a little bit so that word can get in there…does it say pray
let me see v.i.s.i.t … hmm still spells visit.

your post after that still did not make any reference to praying, lets see what you said

@Ibn_Sadique

Well then the Christians don’t have any textual command from ‘On High’ to restrict non-Christians to visit the Vatican. If they had so, then the Vatican would have been out of bounds for non-Catholics.

Whereas Muslims have ‘textual command’ by highest authority to restrict the entry of non-Muslims to the Haram area of Makkah Al Mukarramah. No big Deal!

to which I responded that I was taking about non catholics being allowed to go to vatican and correcting some gap in knowledge.

@X2

I was answering to your point about whether someone who is not christian will be allowed at the Vatican. You were incorrect/not knowledgeable and I fixed that. Now that we know that in fact non catholics can go to vatican, we can close that argument off. No Big Deal!

Cheers

Had you said 3 posts ago that you knew non muslims can visit vatican, that would have been helpful to us all, but you ended with exclamation of 'no big deal!" .. not sure if there was a place for that but sure..

and now since we are talking about superior knowledge and observation skills…this little nugget may have escaped your notice about praying at Vatican. I know praying was not the topic of our discussion but visit, but since you are now talking about prayers..there is a first..

Vatican makes history: Pope allows Islamic prayers, Koran readings - Washington Times

Cheers