Banning Non Muslims in Makkah

[Med911]

Re: Banning Non Muslims in Makkah

@psyah

You didn’t answer my question. Where in Islam does it specifically forbid us from disallowing non-Muslims into the haram. As far as preventing them from entering there are some subjective references - but can you even provide an indicative reference as to that act being forbidden? And if you cannot then let the government of Saudi do as it wishes.

I think the idea that “Islam is an inclusive religion” is a worthwhile topic in itself. When you say “Islam is inclusive” what limits do you draw on this inclusiveness?

I don’t know… I don’t have the time to do some lengthy research here. I would someone as learned as u would help us in that regard.
The Saudis are safe from me, as I lack a standing army ready to do my bidding. But why should they be the policy makers on matters of faith? What glories have we seen under their stewardship that we should honor them with such a dignity?

The rest later