Ban on processions-Religious rulings?

[Sonador]

Re: Ban on processions-Religious rulings?

@Ma_Mooli

So they shouldn’t be allowed because they are controversial? So only those should be allowed that agree with you or the majorities views?

They shouldn’t be allowed in public because they are a minority ritual and a minority or majority has no right to disturb the life of a whole city. If they have to worship then go to a particular place for that.

Are you happy to ban any public gathering of any sorts? Or is it just the controversial ones that affront your senses?

Any loud and violent gatherings such as those of Aashura must be banned, they scare the kids off!

Do not make it a battlefield, it’s not a war, do not act like an angry battalion that is full of rage. Keep you anger within your heads and sit at your own houses, do not show it off in public.

These killings are occurring on a daily basis and not just around ashura, nor just on processions. They are occurring inside mosques and in buses. Would you like them banned too??

As I said this is not a new phenomena; violence has always been connected to the aashura processions, in all decades. Go open a book of history for the recent past for example.

But you are right that no sane country would allow such violence. They would tighten security and apprehend the attackers beforehand; but this is pakistan. Sane is not a word you would use to describe it.

No sane nation should allow such violent processions as those of aashura.

They carry weapons and chemicals to torch buildings and vehicles with them. A couple of years ago, they torched business centres in the old Karachi and vehicles and banks etc because there was a terrorist attack on the procession.

Torching public and private property and vehicles is a norm to such people.

I hope you don’t want me to provide you with links in order to prove the above?

Take you for example; instead of blaming the attackers for the violence; you put the blame on the people who simply want to carry out their tradition. You are more offended at the juloos rather than the culprits. See the twisted logic = twisted brains.

Perhaps some people attack you because you incite hatred and cause controversy. The incitement of crime is as bad as is the crime.

Make your mind up. Either these sectarian attacks are occurring on ashura or they are not? You seem confused!!

Sectarian attacks are perpetrated upon the aashura processions and from the attendants of such processions. Terrorists and extremists are on both sides.

And sectarian killings are a form of lawlessness dear; they are not excluded in anyway.

That’s why shut the door that opens sectarian killings.

Im not sure what you are talking about here. My point is processions and parades occur everywhere… Including muharram ones! They are not specific to your country that you are so bothered…so stop whinging and find something better to do.

We don’t care what’s happening at other places, we only care for our own country. In our country these Muharram processions cause violence, killings and law and order problems. Simply ban them!