Ban Indian films and TV

Indian (Hindi) cultural invasion should be stopped. The occupied nations of Tamils, Assamese, Nagas, Manipurans, Tripurans, Mizos, Telugus, Keralans, Goans, Sikhs are sick and tired of crappy Indian films/TV which are corrupting and destroying their culture. Bangladesh, Nepal, Bhutan, Sri Lanka, Pakistan, and Afghanistan should learn from them. Keep the ban on Indian films and TV indefinitely!

Separatists issue edict against Hindi films

Thursday November 20, 2004
The Guardian

Bollywood films have been banned by rebel groups throughout India’s troubled north-eastern region because their “erotic song and dance numbers” have been deemed a bad influence on young minds.

In a rare show of solidarity, nine armed separatist groups across five states, including Assam, have issued an edict against the popular Hindi films from Bombay’s film factories.

“Hindi films are part of an ugly Indian media campaign of cultural aggression, endangering the very survival of the unique cultural identity of the indigenous people,” said a tribal Bodo rebel leader in Assam.

A similar ban, imposed two years ago, is in place in Manipur state, which borders Burma.

Soldiers and armed police have begun guarding cinemas, as well as the homes and offices of people involved in the film industry.

Film distributors initially tried to reason with the rebel leaders, and even offered to snip “titillating” scenes from Bollywood romances.

But the rebels refused the offer, saying that their objections were not just to cinematic “obscenity” but to “Indian cultural imposition”.

Bollywood produces a few hundred Hindi films every year and dominates India’s film business, often snuffing out more authentic regional cinema. But in Assam and Manipur, regional cinema survives.

The rebel groups have been seeking to channel resentment against Bollywood, and hostility towards Indians who come from outside the north-eastern region remains high.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

y don't u ask pakistanis not to watch Indian movies? If they r crappy, and Pakistanis like crappy, then probably we have to raise the education level in pakistan. In all cases, the responsibility is on pakistan to raise the intellectual level of avg pakistani.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

You must recheck your education level before makling such comments.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

P4e - go right ahead and ban Indian movies all you want - the people will just sneak dvd's in anyway. It's called ENTERTAINMENT you little pea brain!

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

guess who flunked their south asian geography class. :hehe:

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

^ ^ :rotfl:

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

baning indians movies is a lame and idiotic idea.

but what really amuses me is the fact that paki tv channels always are saying things like "friendship with india" etc etc they are always inviting indians onto their shows, and on the other hand when ever i tune into some indian tv channel they are showing this anti pak movie or drama! losers really. but what the hey, we pakis even watch thos dramas and movie with interest lol

mind u i dont watch tv much, only once in a long long while.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

Every time one hears of Bollywood’s popularity outside of India, what comes to the mind first are Indian ex-pats in the UK, US, Singapore, UAE, the Pakistanis, the Afghans, the Soviet Union of the 50s. Well, at least, that was how I perceived it. However I was pleasantly surprised to learn that there are people from one of our other neighbors who are very fascinated by Bollywood. The Chinese!! It was during my initial meetings with some of my Chinese colleagues (both men and women) that this fact was made known to me. “You are an Indian right? Oh! I really like Indian movies. Indian women very beautiful. I like that, song and dance. So much colour. I like all that color” they tell me in halting English. I must add here, though totally out of context, that in my interactions with Chinese women, I found that they do not flinch from telling another woman that she is beautiful. It was very refreshing. Coming back to the original subject, this really caught me unawares (the liking for Indian movies). They don’t know the names of the movies (some of them did remember the Chinese names of the Bollywood flicks), the names of the actors or actresses and some of them don’t even quite understand the movie completely but they love it and they watch it. They watch it with Chinese subtitles or dubbed in Chinese. So here we are, missing not a single opportunity to complain about the quality of Bollywood movies and there we have our neighbors liking the very same movies. However, it does give one a lot of satisfaction to hear nice things said about ones country or culture (even if it is just about Bollywood), from a foreigner.

Another time I had similar conversations was with some Iranian cab drivers on the way home from work. One of them told me that Gadar was a very nice movie and that it was a “must watch”. He also thought Sholay was a very good movie. Yes, he actually knew the name of the movie, Sholay. He sounded very happy to have met me and told me with a wide smile that he was my neighbor from Iran. It was almost like he felt connected to me, far away from his land in an alien soil, through Bollywood.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

Well that sucks..I was just speaking ot a Paki friend of mine and we were going to invest some money in Pakistan and Bring Paki Idol to the masses. Imgaine Lahorans writhing to J-LO. :love: I guess we will have to think about doing this in Saudi Arabia now…

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

Pakistani Idol maybe on it’s way. ‘Indian Idol’ was created by Simon Fuller with Sony Entertainment. Simon Fuller may well bring Pakistan Idol as part of World Idol series.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

Indian channels via cable or satellite and films should be banned in
Pakistan. All Pakistanis should boycott the various means of Indian
media. The damage done to Pakistanis with Indian channels and films
is infinite:

  • They promote Indian/Hindu culture, language, and values

  • They promote Indian political propaganda against Pakistan/Muslims

  • They promote indecency, sex, violence, and vulgarity

The result is:

  • The destruction of the Pakistan's media (film/tv/etc) industry, affecting
    the local economy

  • Cultural invasion from India, and destruction of local cultures and
    values

  • Wasting of precious time of the Pakistanis with garbage

  • And then, Pakistanis are brainwashed with:

--- Hindu/Indian culture

--- Pro-India and anti-Pakistan views

--- Un-Islamic and anti-Islamic values

Some Pakistanis are against any ban or boycott with the argument of
freedom of media/expression/globalization. But what they dont realize
is that some time protectionism is the only choice when national
interests are at risk. Let us face it, Indian media is extremely
powerful and well established, and there is no way that Pakistan can
compete fairly with them in a free environment. In an era when
military wars are becoming insignificant, media is the new potent
weapon utilized by the enemy for their benefit. Let us act before its too late.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

Even within India, different "occupied nations" are againt Indian films and TV:

Separatists issue edict against Hindi films

Thursday November 20, 2004
The Guardian

Bollywood films have been banned by rebel groups throughout India's troubled north-eastern region because their "erotic song and dance numbers" have been deemed a bad influence on young minds.

In a rare show of solidarity, nine armed separatist groups across five states, including Assam, have issued an edict against the popular Hindi films from Bombay's film factories.

"Hindi films are part of an ugly Indian media campaign of cultural aggression, endangering the very survival of the unique cultural identity of the indigenous people," said a tribal Bodo rebel leader in Assam.

A similar ban, imposed two years ago, is in place in Manipur state, which borders Burma.

Soldiers and armed police have begun guarding cinemas, as well as the homes and offices of people involved in the film industry.

Film distributors initially tried to reason with the rebel leaders, and even offered to snip "titillating" scenes from Bollywood romances.

But the rebels refused the offer, saying that their objections were not just to cinematic "obscenity" but to "Indian cultural imposition".

Bollywood produces a few hundred Hindi films every year and dominates India's film business, often snuffing out more authentic regional cinema. But in Assam and Manipur, regional cinema survives.

The rebel groups have been seeking to channel resentment against Bollywood, and hostility towards Indians who come from outside the north-eastern region remains high.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

You can't "ban" Indian Satellite channels, because anyone with a satellite dish can pick them up. The current ban in place only affects terrestial broadcasts and cable TV. Anyone anywhere in Pakistan, be it Karachi or in Wana, can freely watch Indian films through sticking a satellite dish on top of their house.

Not to mention the ease with which you can get Indian DVDs in Pakistan.

Whilst I do see some reasons for favouring a ban, the only net result of banning Pakistani channels from showing Indian movies is that Pakistanis are switching to watching Indian channels via satellite instead.

So instead of watching Pakistani TV with the occasional Indian movie, Pakistanis are watching straight Indian TV. And, like I said, there's nothing the government can do to stop it since you cannot physically prevent a satellite channel from being received anywhere in a country.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

Even with satellite there are ways to block the waves of specific stations … or just ban the public from having dishes.

Those who break the law should be fined with heavy penalties.

But the other solid way to control is to change the national language from Urdu to Farsi or Arabic. Urdu and Hindi are almost the same languages. Urdu as the national language of Pakistan is not only imposing an ethnic (Muhajir) minority’s language on Pakistan but more so causes cultural invasion from India with its huge Hindi media outlets. Once Pakistanis transition from speaking Urdu to Farsi or Arabic, this Indian threat will diminish as Pakistanis wont be able to comprehend any Indian language! Refer: Yahoo | Mail, Weather, Search, Politics, News, Finance, Sports & Videos

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

^ Hey kid..wanna see a clip of Meera kissing that hindu and then dancing atop a car in ouring rain…lemme know.. :k:

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

Thats not true anymore, it was but not now, since all these channels are paid channels now, and require subscriptions, but the Government is allowing cable operators who get these channel subscriptions from Dubai etc to broadcast these channels to the masses, as without them, the Cable Operators would go out of business.

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

If you ban indian films what will they watch?

Pakistani films......Im sorry but no-one deserves that kind of punishment:D

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

Once Pakistanis stop watching Indian films/tv because of a stronger/realistic ban implemented (and perhaps due to change of national language from Urdu to Farsi or Arabic) ... Pakistani film/tv industry will be able to grow because of the local demand ... but the key here would be not to copy Indian crap ... be more independent and creative ... employing local cultures along with modernism for entertainment... keeping it decent and artistic... Iran's little film industry is a classic example...

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

Haww haiy…Hindu…she should have danced with a Kristian…like Yousuf Youhanna…

Re: Ban Indian films and TV

nicols_john that’s true, as well as Iranians, the Afghans, Arabs and even some Turkish people are obsessed with India because of their movies and stuff. If I tell them I’m an Indian they are so in awe of me and friendly but if I tell them the truth they’re more reserved.

I wonder why everyone looks down on us Pakis so much. :frowning:

Saara Jinnah ka qusoor hai. :mad: