Are today's muslims, yesterday's Bani Israeel?

[psyah]

Re: Are today’s muslims, yesterday’s Bani Israeel?

@Mr.Popat

That’s what i’m saying sir. Sahabah did not forget that Muhammad PBUH told about Dajjal being one-eyed, whose ride will be donkey whose ears will be some feet apart from eachother, who will eat fire, who will travel across the world within hours etc.. and despite that, they referred a man dajjal who was neither one eyed, and had no such ride. Did you see Muhammad PBUH telling sahabah that he cannot be dajjal since hes not one-eyed? Are you then telling me that sahabah forgot ? are you telling me that Prophet Muhammad PBUH took his words back about dajjal being one eyed?

Regarding my comment on Imam Al bukhari (ra), I only talked about it since you give me the explanation that this and this way is how sahabah understood .. that’s when I said that the ahadith were compiled around 200 years after His death.. what makes you think the way you understood any concept today is how sahabah understood it too ? This is the role of Messiah. He will be hakam adal.. His words about the authenticity of something will stand correct as long as the explanation he gives are in complete accordance to Quran and obviously whatever wahi he will receive. I said this to ask ibn e sadique what does he have objection with ? what will he do when the same is being done by Jesus(as)? Will you listen to him or your scholars ? whatever your answer will be is my answer. It’s as simple as i can explain him. He’s pretty fond of quoting that statement though.

Prophet Muhammad PBUH have foretold about today’s era. He foretold about dajjal being one eyed (worldly eye shining,while blind from spiritual eye), He foretold about the time when Muslim Ummah will be just like jews. He referred to first and last 10 verses of surah kahf to understand who dajjal is. He PBUH said Messiah will kill swine and break cross. He said dajjal will ride a donkey who will eat fire , will be fast in travelling etc. He PBUH said lunar and solar eclipse will occur at the time of Mahdi’s arrival.. Quran says sun and moon will be brought together as a sign of the hour. Messiah is told to be the sign of the hour by hadith. Need I say more ??

We have given brain. We have given logic. We have given Quran. Here’s your chance to break free the ideologies you refer as Islam and think. Think whether what you’re doing is in accordance to Islam. To criticize is easy, but to be neutral is very hard. May Allah enable you to see the true light of Islam and enable you to be a part of it. Ameen.

Peace Mr.Popat

Please provide me the evidence where you think that it was the Sahabah’s consensus in believing that some person who was not one-eyed was Dajjal. As I said, RasoolAllah (SAW) did give this clarification … he (SAW) told his companions (for the reason that if they were concerned about whether they would recognise the Dajjal or not) that he could be RECOGNISED for that fact that he is one-eyed … It is subsequently the consensus position that Dajjal is one-eyed and a man. It is also consensus that the donkey is a metaphor … you are trying to assert that the hadith speak on behalf of all of the Shahabah at the same time - they don’t. I said some people got things wrong … So if you want to take this further - bring a specific hadith or set of ahadith and we will study them together.

To add if you can find out the timing of when those hadith were stated … because the timing will tell us when the Sahabah (RA) were aware of the fact that Dajjal would be one-eyed.