Re: Are today’s muslims, yesterday’s Bani Israeel?
Again.. not going to quote every little thing you write.
Easy to point fingers, isnt it ? Now listen to me with your ears open and with your brain fully functioning.
Muhammad PBUH was called ‘Ibn e Kabsha’ by His people. Because His beliefs resembled a person who died before Him who was called Ibn e Kabsha. Despite people knowing His name was Muhmmad Ibn e Abdullah Ibn e Abdul Mutlib (pbuh). Reason why is that it is common practice in Arab to give the name of someone who came earlier to someone who resemble him in personality and characteristics.
Giving the name of Isa to Messiah sent to Muslims by characteristic ( like isa a.s was sent in bani israel to unite bani israel, his teachings such that he was a peace loving person, someone who was a jew, who obeyed musvi shariyah etc ) and since there is no Mahdi except Isa ( Ibn e maajah’s hadith ), Muhammad PBUH clarified by saying His name will be like his name.. meaning dont think he will be from someone outside.. he will be following Muhammadi shariyah. In one hadith it mentions .. his coming is as if I’m coming back (metaphorically).
When John the baptist was referred as Elijah by Jesus (as). When Muhammad PBUH was referred as Ibn e Kabsha. When Hazrat Aisha (ra) was referred as companion of Yusuf(as)>> ( when Hz Muhammad PBUH insisted Hz Abu Bakr(ra) to lead prayer and Hz Aisha(ra) kept telling him to ask someone else to lead the prayer ). When a man in Makkah was referred as Dajjal. Why can the Messiah not be named Isa, why cant Mahdi who is the Messiah be referred as Muhammad Bin Abdullah ?
You are the one denying truth when everything has been shown to you clearly! You are the one who are following the footsteps of jews by insisting that you will not believe in any person if their names are not such and such etc…exactly like jews ! and wait a minute.. how does it make me jew-like to follow a false messiah ?? huh, come again ?? they’re still waiting for their Messiah who will bring peace in the world, who will re-gain jewish power, who will reunite bani israel. Give me a break. Atleast refrain from calling someone else jewish-like when you know whose acting like jews.
What justification you as a Muslim would give to Jews about how Isa Ibn e Maryam(as) was infact the true Messiah for them?
This is your condition. May Allah forgive you. You are putting scholars work of sorting out ahadith superior to someone who will be coming from Allah who will tell you the correct interpretation of ahadith and which are correct/weak/unauthentic etc. May Allah forgive you for what you have to say simply to object on Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as).
Islam is a complete religion. How does a divinely guided person telling you which ahadith are to be taken how.. would make you think its adding or subtracting something from Islam ? what’s wrong with you buddy ? Islam is complete. Why are there so many sects ? Allah refrains Muslims from following any sect. Yeah, a sect which is started by the prophet of Allah is the one Allah has liked. When a prophet comes, everyone is going to the same direction.. it is then when Allah saves humanity by sending a prophet and from Him he establishes a Jamaat who does work to reunite the ummah by presenting clear understanding of concepts ummah has been confused about. This is the way of Allah. This is the history of earliest ummah you can go back to.
May Allah enable you to read my post with an open heart. Ameen.