Are today's muslims, yesterday's Bani Israeel?

[Ibn_Sadique]

Re: Are today’s muslims, yesterday’s Bani Israeel?

@Mr.Popat

lol. You’re funny.
I have explained this to you many times. You just dont seem to get it.

I am not surprised that you find it funny. The simple reason that I don’t seem to ‘get it’ is that you are explaining it with a twist and slant of your faith’s requirements. Sorry no takers.

@Mr.Popat

Quran is the word of Allah and therefore not a single word or letter of it is or can be changed. Every single word is preserved.

The above is correct BUT ‘you guys’ manipulate/twist/ distort/ misinterpret the Blessed Words of Allah Almighty to suit your faith’s requirements. Sorry no takers.

@Mr.Popat

Ahadith on the other hand , however, were compiled some 200 years after holy prophet pbuh’s death. Do you know Imam Bukhari discarded thousands and thousands of ahadith because he figured there was a man writing fake ahadith?

The hadith books were compiled 130 to 180 hijrah but you must remember that hadith material was committed to the memory too.

The noble Imam Bukhari (ra) has already done an excellent job sorting out the sahih ahadith from the forged ones.

So no need for some pretender/imposter to reject or ‘invent’ new hadith to suit his nefarious agenda.

@Mr.Popat

We believe Hz Ahmad(as) to be the same reformer, Imam Mahdi and Promised Messiah which was foretold by Prophet Muhammad PBUH. And mind you, he is suppose to be the hakam and adal person. No one can tell which hadith is true and which is not UNLESS and UNTIL that person is from Allah. Are there not already categories of ahadith being strong , weak etc ? who gave them the authority ? It is the Messiah who will tell Muslims which ahadith stands correct and which is not, and He will explain to Muslim ummah the true explanation of ahadith as well.

You can believe what you like as that is your free choice.

Imam Mahdi’s name will be (Hz) Muhammad ibn Abdullah (ra) and he will be from the progeny of the Blessed Prophet Muhammad (saw). The one you follow is named Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani.

Promised Messiah’s name will be (Hz) Isa Ibn Maryum (as). The one you follow is named Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani ibn Chirag Bibi.

Imposter has no rights in Islam! Let alone try to reclassify ahadith to suit his nefarious agenda.

@Mr.Popat

Read the same statement again. This time, consider that Hz Isa (as) himself is saying it, who according to you will come back from skies. Now tell me where do you object ? Will you listen to Hz Isa(as) who will tell you which hadith is wrong and which is right and the explanation he gives for some ahadith ? or will you listen to scholars, who categorized ahadith in the best of their knowledge (not from divine knowledge).

I want to hear the answer from you on this one. Kindly write back to me and tell me what your stance would be on such a scenario ? Thank you.

I will listen to and obey/follow Isa ibn Maryum (as) who will descend in Damascus when Allah almighty wills it.

You my friend are listening to and obeying/following Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani ibn Chirag Bibi.

You can listen to and obey/follow whom you like as that is your free choice.