Are taleban today's kharijiites?

[diwana]

Re: Steeped in ancient mysticism, passion of Pakistani Sufis infuriates Taliban

@Sa1eem

Brother, there is no controversy regarding ‘Najdi hadith’. At least I have never came up with any logical reason or explanation by anyone claiming that ‘Najd is in Iraq’ or ‘any place other than Najd in central Arabia’.

Anyhow whoever consider Najd as a place different from Najd in central Arabia, then they should come up with logical reasons and explanations … and apply that reasons and explanations on hadith to prove their point.

For me … I am as clear that Najd mentioned in Najdi hadith is area around Riyadh … just like I am clear that Lahore where Thug Nawaz lives, is in Punjab-Pakistan.

@Sa1eem

No, you should come up with those hadith … but then, I have read large part of Sahi Bukhari, Sahi Muslim, and Muwatta, and also lot of other hadith books … but never came with any hadith ‘linking Horn of Shaitan with Iraq’ … so if you quote the hadith you are claiming with reference than it would be great thing for my knowledge (and knowledge of all who would read you).

As far as I know, the only hadith some misguided people claim linking ‘Iraq with horn of Shaitan’ is the one I quoted in my earlier post … and along with my quote I also gave explanation why what they claim is absurd.

@Sa1eem

^^^ In History, **no sect **came from Najd in Arabia … east of Medina … who were Staunch Muslim as far as rituals are concerned, are known takfeeries, interpret Quran applying ayahs on Muslims what is meant for Kuffar … and who created fitna and fisad all over Muslim world … and are cause of many killings and mayhem … except the one we are talking about.

Like I said I am not going to do what you are doing just because I have no intention to malign Iraq or any place, either.

Hope readers can search on their own.

Just as a hint: There are people who think Najd could be one of 13 different places. Go figure!

Now please go ahead and convince them too.

Even if I post links or another views against yours you will not accept.

You make up things out of hadiths after reading them and refuse to accept that these kind of hadiths are at best controversial.

Your view is NOT universally agreed upon.

Neither you can prove Qayamat is coming soon nor you can prove wth certainty that Salafis/Wahabis/Ahle Hadiths/those who live in KSA, were meant to be the bad guys by these hadiths.

Sorry, you are promoting sectarians and National hatred here.