Re: Are Shia muslims safer in Pakistan or in india?
Well I can accuse you, because you didnt come up with any numbers to prove otherwise. Ur comments on ram sethu is below belt. It has nothing to do with the discussion that we are having here.
You accused Muslims of being too focused on religious learning, and not scientific enough, despite the fact that only 4% are being educated in madrasas according to your own government's studies.
I was simply pointing out what the level of scientific discourse is in India. It's completely relevant...if you're going to accuse Muslims in general of being backwards people, you should be reminded of the state of your nation as a whole.
Really then why does the second and third generation pakistanies doing the same. Besides if I take ur argument then I could use it in favour of people in India as well. Its not a hidden fact that more wealthy Indians migrated to pakistan in partition leaving the poor behind.
Because, as anyone of a number of social studies will show, the children of poor people are less likely to succeed in school than their wealthier counterparts. They cant afford to go to good schools, they often have to drop out of school early and start working to help support their families, they tend to live in more crime ridden areas, etc.
The migrants that you speak of account for less than 10% of Pakistan's population. In case you weren't aware, the land that makes up Pakistan was not uninhabited prior to Partition...there were indigenous people there, many of whom happened to be poor.
In any case, why are you focusing on the UK? Why not talk about the US, where on average, Pakistanis are better educated and have higher incomes than average? Or would that just defeat your argument that all us Muslims are inherently lazy and stupid?
We didnt say that muslims are well off in India. But atleast there is oppertunity for them to live their life they want. U bring up few examples of places where discrimination exist as a result general enemity between hindus and muslims, and paint that as a true representation of whole of India is very childish.
Please respond to the study on employment that I posted above.
This is so nonsensical it isnt even funny. Its no more ridiculous than if I were to claim that Hindus and Sikhs are better off in Pakistan than in India.