Re: Arab Tablighis
Any scholar who calls for unity is a force for good, unity is not a problem. It is desirable. What is a problem is that a scholar says there was such and such a problem and fails to deliver the Islamic verdict on the issue.
Point noted [that i am standing in a place that is liberal.] Well i am not calling for anyone to be killed, I am calling for people to demand that certain people who said certain things are labelled correctly, with Takfir, when and if people like so called shaykhs speak on the subject. The present day deobandis are not labelled as Kaffirs automatically. No they are Muslims. We are talking about dead people who can not be re-killed but we can distance ourselves from their wrongs. In my view he who fails to criticize them is a Kaffir, and the shayks who criticize them but fail to apply the fatwa that was applied before by the previous shaykhs are misguided
There is Islamic positions that allow for life to be taken. I am not going into all that with you personally. From what you have said it is obvious your stomach may not tolerate it
There is similar expressions in Hadith, and the Quran too. A big gagging order coming along, I can see it - and this is the result of self promotion of extremely moderated shaykhs. This is prevalent in all schools
In these situations the Islamic sentiments (sentiments of Muslims), as recorded in Hadith, are:
‘’…Ya RasoolAllah allow me to chop his head off..‘’
".. “MAY ALLAH’S LANAH BE UPON YOU, IF I EVER HEAR YOU SAYING THIS WORD AGAIN THEN I WILL CHOP YOUR HEADS OFF”
From my prospective, I am calling for a stand against Batil [falsehood]. This might be our last stand left