Arab Tablighis

[psyah]

Re: Arab Tablighis

@vroom

This, underlined, is kufr in the shariah. He admits they do it as a group, not an individual error. Psyah has admitted they do this as a group

The author of this article is lying for them because imkan e khadib came before deoband but he uses it as an example to say what crept in. Not impressed

Peace brother vroom

innovated expressions and concepts that are rightly deemed as tantamount to disparaging the Holy Prophet Muhammad*,

*This is not kufr … and the reason is as so:

tantamount = approaching
disparaging to be kufr has to be by intent to disparage … A poor statement is not kufr in and of itself if it can be first established what the intent is behind that statement.

Lowering the high rank of RasoolAllah (SAW) is bad … I understand that all too well through my learnings from my tariqah … but if the intent is to be prudent about shirk then we cannot accuse those Deobandi brethren of being kaafir … they are merely being too over-protective of shirk that it causes difficulties of adab with RasoolAllah (SAW).

This is the type of fault that Deobandis are entering … regardless of this - I can still follow most of what they teach and I do … but I try to take my belief system from chains connected to Imam At-Tahawi … more closely to source … I try to avoid anti-Deobandi polemics … better to go to source …