Answering 10 Questions regarding Hadees

[usmanshahid]

Re: Answering 10 Questions regarding Hadees

@USResident

Sorry I’ve been busy as well.

no problem

1 - Agreed. There are numerous ahadith, which discuss the historical accounts of happenings in the Prophet SAW time without giving some injunction or commandment

Ahadees are classified by Ulmmahs and imams and ahadees where direct wording of Hazoor PBUH have higer category then one which are only seen
again the same problem
Ulmmahs and imams work are vanishing today and classification are getting distroyed
but the what we agree on what Hazoor PBUH says and do were only on the command of Allah swt

2 - Agreed.
3 - Disagreed. Both have generalities and specifications.

i have talk in general terms , means most of them

4 - Agreed on Quran part. Disagreed on Hadith part. Some ahadith may be verbatim what the Prophet SAW said however not all. Some may carry the same meaning but not the verbatim verbiage.

again the same classification problem

5 - Agreed.
6 - Absolutely.