The point was, you cant claim to be a multi ethnic nation, where everyone lives together in peace, and then at the same time, claim to be divided into states based on different ethnicity. Its a contradiction. If you were truly mutlti ethnic, where everyone gets along so well, then why the need for seperate states?
It is technicaly wrong to call any Indian state ethnic, ethnic are people who are not native to the land they live in or individuals who think he or she belong to other nation once your generation next start thinking they belong to the nation then you are non-ethnic, what i want to say is the apparent difference inside India, the thing is for a man language and culture comes first than the religion which Pakistan never understood even after Bangladesh who are Bengali speaking Muslims the same sort of thing is happening in Baluchistan and in some tribal areas of Pakistan, as Indians become more socially developed they will crisscross the country and in fact it has already started happening but the only state where an article 370 prevents us from settling is Jammu and Kashmir.
What is the point of having India even existing if the same reults could be produced by creating completely seperate countries out of your already ethnically sepearate states??!?!
yes we can, nobody is preventing us but have you ever thought about why the states are living together, do you think it is because of Hinduism, then why are states like Karnataka, Maharashtra, etc are rich while states like Bihar and UP are poor, we are together because we believe in India it is because what we can achieve together is for beyond what we can achieve without being together
India can be secualr or religous, but thats not my concern. Hindutva has been alive and well in India for far longer then you assume. Im sure
for some socially under developed people they have seen basically Hindu society getting converted to Islam and Christianity for over hundreds of years so they have come up with there own ideology which says India should be a fundamental Hindu country and we should protect Hindus, so what about Islamic fundamentalism, soon to become biggest religion in this world why do Islam need fundamental radical ideology, unfortunately people who follow are fundamental to spread there own power interest people have created fundamentalism.
after nearly two decades of growth you are immensly optamistic, but reality doesnt always follow the optimisitc route.
man man man, India is printing its own money, we do have all the resources to look after our self, the challenge is to control the population and to find jobs or create jobs for everyone, it is the apparent realization of the simple fact that if we create our own solutions technically, scientifically, economically, etc then we do not have to worry about numbers.
Your asking me who said they dont want to be India? How about the people of Kashmir?!?! Jammu is a Hindu majority area and so they obviously would join Hindu dominant INDIA. But a little research would help you immensly.
there are about 150 million Muslims in India where they should be going ? generation next of Muslims who did not want to go with Pakistan when Pakistan was created as a Islamic state. there are only 7 million Muslims living in Jammu and Kashmir.
Australia is a majority white anglo saxon nation. Despite that fact, Australians were able to beat every team during much of this decade. Other countries that have risen. America's rise started in early 20th century. This despite the factt that it was greatly homogenous in terms of ethnicity after having completely sidelined the black minority.
Japan despite being a relatively unifrom nation, still rose to the heights of today.
There are many ethnically homogenous countires that have done realtively well.. So where is the benefit of ethnic plurality?
i am not saying homogeneous nations cannot develop in the 21st century, India is most trying to become homogeneous in nature by insignifiying our linguistic, religious, racial, ethnic differences, what i am saying is that one cannot say my race is superior like the Hitler saying the blue eyeied Germans are the superior race like some of the Chines who are saying Chines are the superior race or my religion or language is superior what we are saying is all people are equal in India
if Australians are Anglo Saxon majority nation so they are winning then are you saying that they are superior because they are white so they are winning then you are self discriminating, why England is not winning, Americans have more gold medals in Athletics because of the African Americans in basket ball and in so many other sports, Brazil is the best foot ball nation the world.
USA is the best example of ethnic plurality, the whole of America is ethnic except for the Indians Americans old Indians not the India, USA is the number one nation because it is Pluralistic, it is leading in every field known to man because it is pluralistic, take NASA it is at the forefront of human space exploration because it is made up of so many different ethnic people with vastly different thoughts.
ok, happy Independence Day,