And you didn’t answer my questions Mr… would you offend Prophet or go for the money, and where did it say he offended Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. to feed the needy, oh please… Oh a khaleefa is confessing himself he introduced a biddat on top of it in one of the hadith’s he increased the # of rakats… and watz that… first of all you didnt prove if taraweeh…was actually practice by Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. and if so how many rakats was it… why don’t you pray four rakat of fajar…thinking its a good practice as Umar said increasing the rakats of taraweeh is…
and also I want your explaination on the ayat on the questions I asked you not one but several times…
[QUOTE] Originally posted by ThandyMazaq
greediness....secondly, the prophet himself prayed taraweeh salat in his last ramadhan, for 3 straight nights in JAMAH, and he then left them because he did not want them to be taken by his ummah to be obligatory, but after his death, no one was going to take the words of omar as rulings in religion. so he said that i can revive the sunnah of taraweeh...and to this day no one believes tarahweeh salat to be obligatory, EVERY one knows that it is sunnah that we can pray if we want...so that ends your theory about omar introducing new stuff to islam...he just followed one sunnah that he thought was good and no one took his word as ruling in islam....
[/QUOTE]
Taraweeh is the prayer which Ahe Sunnah pray in congregation after Isha Prayer in the holy month of Ramazan. They complete recitation of the whole Quran atleast once in this prayer during the whole month. Rakat of Taraweeh is not fixed in them.
Taraweeh is bidah because of the following reasons:
(1) It was never offered by Prophet Muhammad in the whole month of Ramazan.
(2) The holy prophet never offered this prayer after the Isha Prayer.
(3) It was never offered in the designated location of the mosque.
(4) Prophet disliked those people who called them for the prayer which he offered for three days in the last part of night before dawn.
(5) Abu Bakar who was authority for Ahle Sunnah, never offered Taraweeh in his life.
(6) Umar ordered to prayer, but never offered the Taraweeh prayer himself in his life.
(7) Umar did not ordered the Taraweeh prayer in his early years of Khalafa. it was 17th year of his khalafa.
(8) Umar never gave the reason of Fear while ordering Taraweeh prayer. He was simply passing by and saw people prayer without a group and than ordered them to pray in congregation. which is not a hujat for muslimeen
(9) Alhe Bait and their imams never offered taraweeh prayer in their life.
(10) Ali and Hassan (AS) condemned this act in Kufa when it was their khalfat time.
(11) Taraweeh prayer is not proved from Sahah Sita books.
why is she God that she cant make a mistake?
nauzubillah
[/QUOTE]
Why is that God who says that Fatima(AS) will never make mistake and she makes mistakes.?nauzubillah
i dont have time to reply to all of your points
but first, abu bakar RA had no personal benefit from the fadak property, it was used to feed the hungry take care of the needy and prepare the governemnt's armies against islam. so abu bakar did not get any personal beenfit for us to accuse him of greediness
[/QUOTE]
You dont have TIME or you dont have ANYTHING inside you to reply those points. anyway. In fact Ahle Sunnah dont have the concept of Khums which is the explicit teachings of Quran. that is why they are in problem. they did have money to run the Government, instead of finding some solution they took control of Fadak (Qubza) and fabricated a hadith in favor of that act. wasalam