Amir Muwiya's conversion to Islam

[shardmanny]

Re: Amir Muwiya’s conversion to Islam

@Surdar_Asif

What was the terms of this pledge? (I am not sure where you got the idea of ‘allegiance’ from?) And how is it merit of Muawiya that Hassanain signed and stayed loyal to a pledge with him? If anything then it again shows the truthfulness and nobility of the Hassanain.
If you are suggesting that Hassanain detested the idea of fighting Muawiya then you do not have to look too far back in Siffin when both fought along with their brother, Abbas and Mohammad, against the king of Sham. More than 70 veterans of Badr and Ohad took part in Siffin against Muawiya.

these questions are for you to answer first so we may understand each other

what was the manner of his pledge/allegience? did he cross his left hands fingers behined his back?
we believe Hassan RA is noble but in your religion how does it show the nobility of a man who liked fighting Muawiya RA, but is now giving such a man (as you view Muawiya RA) a pledge?
nobody is denying that Ali RA took his forces to Siffeen, Syria to gain the pledge from Muawiya RA and eventually had a battle. the battle was fierce and so were sentiments, yet no takfir.
and if you believe there was takfir then what about Hassans (RA) pledge and Al-Husseins (RA) rising during yazids time not Muawiyas ra (20 years)?

Why does the son of Abu Sufyan gets to have this privilege but this is not extended to the son of Hazrat Abu Bakr. What about Ammar Yasir (one of the earliest person to be converted to Islam, also praised in Quran),

they get same priviliges as Uthman RA, Talha RA and Al-Zubayr RA. they were killed during the Fitnah