American marines insulting dead bodies

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

Like I've said, Americans do underhanded things and so do your idols, the Taliban. It's pretty clear you support these nuts, which makes you just as bad as the war mongering Republicans, and either makes you a bad Muslim or a Muslim not at all.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

i find your comments hypocritical

how can you defend the action of the US administration which are war crimes in all but name and then call muslims bad or worse kafir?

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

I'm not defending the US. The Taliban are not Muslims. If that's your idea of Islam then you have problems.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

what you are saying is true for an independent free and justified thinker free of any bigotted biases. but here you are argueing with few persons who think it is duty of every muslim to support taliban ,terrorists, killers . if anybody tries to argue with them he is outrightly decleared kuffar .

these are internet jehadis who find solace in any piece of news which can show negative image of america,india,israel .they call everybody who dares to differ an agent of c.i.a. or raw or mossad.
everyday they search internet for such news , and come up with new thread bashing america ,one jehadi based in paris is foremost in this activity.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

Indi. Watchout check the thread purpose and reply on it dont need to drag the topic on indo pak things.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

who are you to call the people fighting illegal occupiers as not muslim who gave you the permission to generalize entire set of people like that, are you muslim?

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

This is pathetic act from so called socialized!

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

All NORMAL Muslims call the Taliban Non Muslim. Who gives us authority? Easy. Allah SWT choose to gift us with rational thought, and capacity to discern right from wrong. Anyone who knows anything of Islam (which obviously excludes you), and hasnt been living under a rock (again you shouldnt apply) for the past 15 years knows the Taliban are UnIslamic fanatics. So logic dictates that those who are UnIslamic are also non Muslim... Simple logic, even you im sure could follow.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

Well done on shirk there.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

Well done on being wrong.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

not even one evidence from islam to back your claim.

Provide one ayah or hadith that allows you kiss the backside of the american kuffar and support them?

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

same goes for you if he wrong

meet the challenge,

Provide one ayah or hadith that allows you to support the american kuffar in places like afghanistan and iraq and support them in their war against the people there?

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

I don't support America, or the Taliban/ Al Qaeda. Both sides are terrorists. Yet you support the latter. So what does that make you?

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

so you don't support american terror forces great finally.

taliban i never said i supported them but i do support any people who involved in resistance against occupation especially against imperial governments like the US and the little wannabe power UK.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

I never said I supported the Americans genius. And the bold part contradicts itself. You just said "I don't support the Taliban, but I support the Taliban." You're not a Muslim, just an extremist. People like you are as bad as Bush. I'm ashamed that you call yourself a Muslim.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

That was extremely infantile coming from you. I expected better. And do ahead and prove how I am wrong?

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

Apologies sir, I did not know I had a rep.

From wiki:

Shirk is the sin of idolatry or polytheism. i.e. the deification or worship of anyone or anything other than the singular God, or more literally the establishment of “partners” placed beside God.

He did not deify anyone, he simply called the Taliban non-Muslims. I would agree. And I’m sure you would too. Their *******ization of Islam is the real crime.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

Shirk is also attributing or taking on abilities which only Allah has the right too. Like its Shirk to say one is equal/greater than Allah and that is either idolatry or polytheism.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

I see the education in United States is worse than in 3rd world countries where even i have to correct your english.

"Taliban i never said i supported them but i do support any people who involved in resistance against occupation especially against imperial governments like the US and the little wannabe power UK."

I stated i support the resistance its starts with the letter r in case you missed that, i know you would love your GI Joe USA military to have a walk over with no resistance but in the real world they facing a resistance. One which humiliated them to the point where they begging the resistance to stop fighting them.

Secular extremists like yourself have no argument, it's too easy to expose them, try reading a book and come back with something more challenging because i am not impressed with the level of debate coming from the united states.

Re: American marines insulting dead bodies

To clarify I do not comment on another man's faith or the claim the ability to judge him. After all Christ said "Ye who is without sin, cast the first stone".