"All knowing"

[sceptic]

Re: “All knowing”

@diwana

That is the essence of my position.

God does not influence it. He lets the person decide.

Hence the person is responsible of his/her act.

Same way, if I gave the child two items. The child decides on his/her own. Not me.

Regardless of what God knows anyone in this world would do, and I knew what the child would do, it makes the person and the child in my example act on free will. Like I said, don’t blame God for wrong choices you (not personally you) make.

**God will judge you for the action you had control on, not when you did not.
**
With all of his mercy, God/Allah gives a lot of chances to human and waits before He decides to put the person responsible.

There is a limit however where human have ability to choose. **And when the ability to choose is not present then, human are not to be punished for their acts.
**
If I get time, no promise but I will write more and basic rules of engagement between God and Human and that will answer 5amra also. Stay tuned.

P.S. Good questions by the way.

Here’s a question for you - can god create a riddle that he cannot solve? Go work on that! LOL.

I can’t say I understand your position (or any religion’s position, since that is what it is) on this, because that is exactly what I am questioning here.

My brother, you DO NOT know what the child will choose. God KNOWS what you will choose, that is the difference. God knew what you will do before you were created, so where exactly does the ‘judgment’ fit in? Judgment is a reaction, how can you react unless you ‘find out’.

Appreciate your input though, and would love it if you would keep it short and crip as you are doing now.