"All knowing"

[diwana]

Re: “All knowing”

@5amra

**I don’t think we have any free will or something like that & we don’t actually choose our paths either by using that free will.**Sometimes I think **Allah makes us choose what he wants us to actually choose. **Either Allah put that in our minds or puts us in a situation where we have no other option & have to do what Allah wants us to do. Obviously we are human beings, we are weak, we are prone to mistakes & we will react to the conditions & situations we are surrounded by but then again who is putting us in this situation? Allah puts us in. **Who created us this much weak? **Allah made us like this. I don’t understand. I have been driving myself crazy for like ages now by thinking all this but there is no answer. I know people say we have free will & all that stuff, I used to think like that too but actually we don’t. **Free will is just an illusion **that’s it as OP said. It’s all about balance. This is a cycle we all are in, may be a time cycle or something. We all are just playing our parts.

To all the **bolded **parts, I must say no.

Allah does not put us in any situation of conflict. We as human somehow choose or are dragged in to conflicting situation.

Aside from diseases and illnesses human suffer without their own fault, if human encounter any conflicting or opposing options, human are free to choose and their choice is what is tested by Allah.

After giving the mind and sending Prophets and scriptures which tells mankind what is good and what is bad, Allah/God is expecting human to act accordingly and not break the rules.

God does not make an individual to choose one or other option. The person does. And despite having a good option, if the person chooses the wrong option, then God is not to be blamed.

**Whole idea of reward and punishment from God in life hereafter (if one believes on it) depends on God being merely an observant and knowing what would happen next without interfering.
**