"All knowing"

[psyah]

Re: “All knowing”

@5amra

I don’t think we have any free will or something like that & we don’t actually choose our paths either by using that free will.Sometimes I think Allah makes us choose what he wants us to actually choose. Either Allah put that in our minds or puts us in a situation where we have no other option & have to do what Allah wants us to do. Obviously we are human beings, we are weak, we are prone to mistakes & we will react to the conditions & situations we are surrounded by but then again who is putting us in this situation? Allah puts us in. Who created us this much weak? Allah made us like this. I don’t understand. I have been driving myself crazy for like ages now by thinking all this but there is no answer. I know people say we have free will & all that stuff, I used to think like that too but actually we don’t. Free will is just an illusion that’s it as OP said. It’s all about balance. This is a cycle we all are in, may be a time cycle or something. We all are just playing our parts.

No … This is not the claim of people … This is from the scriptures … If you don’t understand it, then don’t try to … For myself I am satisfied as there is plenty of room analogically to understand this … Also faith has to be in scripture not in our ability to understand.

the free will of humanity plus the Qadr of Allah (SWT) both are true without doubt.