This might be my last post here as there is no point repeating the same issue over and over.
The main difference between an ahmadi muslim and other sects of muslim is some minor beliefs that differ. And these different beliefs should not be held responsible for Ahmadis to be declared non-muslim in any way.
- difference in belief of Jesus ... ( alive or dead )
- acceptance of Imam Mehdi .. ( which other muslims believe will come too ..so accepting the one who claimed to be one shouldnt be a problem )
- Different point of view on khatam e naboowat.
beliefs that ahmadi share with the rest of muslim umma
- Tauheed
- Namaaz 5 times, in the direction of khaana ka'aba
- Hajj ( though it isnt allowed for us, but its every ahmadi muslims's dream just like any other muslim to perform hajj atleast once in their lifetime.)
- Zakat
- Fast
- Belief in angels
- Belief in all messengers (including beloved prophet Muhammad pbuh)
- Belief in all of the Allah's book. And Quran being the last words of Allah for mankind
- Belief in Ahadith
- Belief in the day of Judgement.
You decide , if someone does all the above , but just differentiate some beliefs (such as believing Jesus AS as dead , accepting Imam Mehdi )..from other Muslims.. will you really take him out of the pale of Islam?..
nuff said !
ps: psyah , you wrote the hadith in the same manner i wrote, but the interpretation you are doing differs. I didnt hear anything from you about the usage of the term Qamar and not Hilal in that hadith. And beside, whichever prophecy has been fulfilled , you then come and say that hadith is weak. well done buddy.. carry on..
im out. Enough of this already.